Clan XP Loss

[useless]

Actually, the PVP equivalent to Clan Level Perks would be the extra loot bonus, which increases as you rank up. As does Clan Level Perks. See a pattern?

thats small as a .... i dont know some one say something very small

while in another hand when u lvl up ur clan u got a lot of bonus like extra loot like collecters extra space in CC like real storage extra giving troops(like barracks) and extra lvl for troops(like labs )

also as i said above this will make a lot of players stop warring stop complaining for nothing and clash on

[NF2335]

Why do you want to lose clan XP?

[useless]

Why do you want to lose clan XP?

(not enough that i success everyone else should fail)thats the OP logic

[Goobers]

As it stands, every active, warring clan currently in existence will at some point reach max Clan Level. When that day comes, perks aside, clan level will be meaningless. I suggest, in some form or another, ways to lose Clan XP.

As it stands, every active, farming player currently in existence will at some point max their base. When that day comes, new content excluded, farming will be meaningless. I suggest, in some form or another, ways to lose levels on your defenses and even possibly your troop levels.

[wolpak]

I mentioned this a while ago, when the update was first released. Anyone who says you cannot lose "experience" must be under the age of 30. Over time, all skills degrade, and the less you use them, the worse they get.

I think clan exp should just degrade over time. Maybe 5 points a day. I don't know what a good number would be, but, if you don't keep on warring and/or the clan has almost been abandoned, their clan level should start dropping. You should have to maintain your clan level, not just achieve it and leave it.

[useless]

I mentioned this a while ago, when the update was first released. Anyone who says you cannot lose "experience" must be under the age of 30. Over time, all skills degrade, and the less you use them, the worse they get.

I think clan exp should just degrade over time. Maybe 5 points a day. I don't know what a good number would be, but, if you don't keep on warring and/or the clan has almost been abandoned, their clan level should start dropping. You should have to maintain your clan level, not just achieve it and leave it.

will lets use games logic then (not only clash) do u lose exp??the anser is no on most game


even if real live lose it but the real point of the game is to be fun not logicall ur idea is no fun for almost all players (i would say only 3 said something about this)

if clash was logical u would restart from the start once someone smash u would u like that??bravo of u do

[Davidbaker]

dude this is stupid. I would be so annoyed going into a clan war thinking ill gain exp but instead lose exp

[ironagedave]

That point is a long way off. They can add further clan levels if they wish (funny thing is that guys are already posting requests saying they want to see more even though no one is even close to reaching that point). They might do nothing and let you hit the ceiling. What would you do about it if they reach that point? Quit? Walk away from everything you invested in the game to get that far? its possible they are assuming that by that point they have you pretty locked in. Not a bad assumption.

Agree if they can add new troops, defences levels - they can introduce new tiers for clan levels - why are we playing the game if we aren't trying to max everything if there is no sight of the 'outer limit' it would be a very disheartening game.

Given the fact they are currently offering double xp - i think supercell feel fairly confident and have a big update near the offing.

In other words just KTF.

PS if you are using clan xp as an indicator of how good a clan is at war without using any other indicator is a poor method indeed. That is like saying the dude has a maxed base he has to be good (when in fact he could have just bought it on ebay). War history in the log or experiencing a couple of wars with the clan is a far better indicator - it is the most current and accurate information a player could have IMO.

[ironagedave]

PPS: you don't loose xps's when you lose in multiplayer battles - why should you lose xps in clan war battles. In my opinion losing xps is dipping dangerously close to the negative stats that supercell wish to avoid.

[OzAudi]

Oz, obviously, one would lose XP in a manner similar to which one gained it in the first place. Winning battles in Clan War will gain your clan a small amount of XP, why shouldnt losing an attack cost you some amount. The same as the trophy system. And quite a few clans will stick around, and the new ones made will ALSO hit max Level.

Sorry but they are EXPERIENCE POINTS. It is impossible to lose an EXPERIENCE.

Oz, and yes pre update, Clan Levels didnt even exist, but its a system they implemented. And am I honestly the only one here who sees the Clan Level as an indicator to the actual experience and skill of the clan itself? Right now, you could search for a Level 4 clan, find one, and know that theyre a decent war clan, but what about when everyones clan hits max? Yes there will be new ones, but THEYLL hit max, and so on and so forth. Is the loss of Clan War XP REALLY so stupid an idea?? Cause the same system works wonderfully, i think, with trophies.

Clan level alone, tells you nothing of the clan apart from the their total.EXPERIENCE since the update. And never will. It does not tell you the win/loss ratio. It does not tell you war frequency. It does not tell you their most recent war record. It does not tell you the last time they warred. It does not tell you the last time they won a war. And guess what else ? Taking XP points away from clans will not change any of the preceding points.

Oh and final thing, in what way does it make sense to GAIN XP for a successful attack, but nothing happens when you lose??

Enough losses loses war for the clan and the clan don’t gain XP point for the win component. You don’t think that is sufficient ?




A big issue here is people now think a clan’s level is the one and only way to judge a clan. They swoon, bow and scrape in the presence of high level clans. It s a totally useless method to judge a clan. All it tells you is the perks they enjoy.


Why don’t I like your idea ?
Many clans set impossible war tasks for lower th just to help them improve at war attacks. There is no expectation of them starring. Should the clan be penalized for advancing it’s skill set ?

Once upon a time my clan used lower th to test higher enemy defenses. Again, no expectation of them starring. Should a clan be penalized for using this common tactic ?

One last point. a defeated base offers no additional XP contribution. Under your scheme, if the top half of a clan defeats every base and the bottom half tries snd fails against higher ranking enemy on both attacks..the clan could potentially win the CW but lose XP.

There are so many reasons why this would not work in the way you anticipate yet negatively change the ways many clans operate.