Clan XP Loss

[useless]

real logic :exp = Experience no one lose it in real live unless if he got an Amnesia

clash logic ; the game is about balance u want to punish the noobs and unlucky players for the sake of pro ones??(even most pro wont agree) yes many clans will hit the max lvl but thats mean nothing as every one hit max base but still no pro

[DaWarMan]

Do you even know how long it would take to get clan lvl 10?

[JacoBryan]

Do you even know how long it would take to get clan lvl 10?

And how is that even remotely relevant?

[JacoBryan]

real logic :exp = Experience no one lose it in real live unless if he got an Amnesia

clash logic ; the game is about balance u want to punish the noobs and unlucky players for the sake of pro ones??(even most pro wont agree) yes many clans will hit the max lvl but thats mean nothing as every one hit max base but still no pro

ACTUAL experience, no, you wouldnt lose it. But think of Clan XP working in the same way as trophies.

[useless]

ACTUAL experience, no, you wouldnt lose it. But think of Clan XP working in the same way as trophies.

xp =experience and clans level work the same as base lvl not trophy

[hesto25]

Clan xp should work the same way as a base does.
After all, the time it takes to reach max clan xp is the same time as a base approaches max.

With that in mind, here's a comparison:
If a clan should lose xp by NOT winning,
then a base should lose buildings by NOT building

sound fair? no.

Same implications from the above:
Clan: only the pro players will gain levels
Base: only the hardcore farmers will progress


Also, trophies are fluid (can easily lose and/or win) while clan xp and xp in general is solid (slow moving; concrete) meaning that they should not coexist with each other.

[JacoBryan]

xp =experience and clans level work the same as base lvl not trophy

I know what the hell it means jack wad.
If they used different terminology, your argument wouldnt have a leg to stand on.
Change XP to, in this case, trophies, and Level to,
in this case, Rank. The PVP equivalents to the terms used in the Clan Level system. What im saying is that Clan "XP" should be treated more like Trophies, in the way that losing a fight will set you back, if only slightly.

[JacoBryan]

[QUOTE=hesto25;4256393]Clan xp should work the same way as a base does.
After all, the time it takes to reach max clan xp is the same time as a base approaches max.

With that in mind, here's a comparison:
If a clan should lose xp by NOT winning,
then a base should lose buildings by NOT building

sound fair? no. [\QUOTE]

No, actually. Its not the same. A clan that doesnt
war neither gains XP, nor loses it. A person who doesnt build their base up regularly doesnt lose XP (or buildings, since you found that to be a logical comparison) but doesnt gain any either. So unless they implement a way for you to somehow screw up on building a cannon or something, there really is no logical comparison.

[useless]

I know what the hell it means jack wad.
If they used different terminology, your argument wouldnt have a leg to stand on.
Change XP to, in this case, trophies, and Level to,
in this case, Rank. The PVP equivalents to the terms used in the Clan Level system. What im saying is that Clan "XP" should be treated more like Trophies, in the way that losing a fight will set you back, if only slightly.

change clan XP to, in this case, base XP and levels to ,in this case, base levels

will it fit better to base lvl why?? because trophy dont give u more things or power ups it only show how good u r nothing else

while its already the same as base lvl nothing diff

also think about it clan perks is made so more ppl war will this make ppl happy and war more?? no it wont

[JacoBryan]

change clan XP to, in this case, base XP and levels to ,in this case, base levels

will it fit better to base lvl why?? because trophy dont give u more things or power ups it only show how good u r nothing else

while its already the same as base lvl nothing diff

also think about it clan perks is made so more ppl war will this make ppl happy and war more?? no it wont

Actually, the PVP equivalent to Clan Level Perks would be the extra loot bonus, which increases as you rank up. As does Clan Level Perks. See a pattern?