Would it be nice to attack your fellow clan members for fun ! ! ! SUPERCELL COME COME

[stephenSpk]

who wouldn't want to attack there own clan members… anyone agree or disagree?

Rules: No Personal Gain, just pure friendly attack on your clan members.

Troops bought will determine how much elixir is given back by the stars you earn from your friendly attack.

1 Star: 1/3 of elixir given back
2 Star: 1/2 of elixir given back
3 Star: Everything is given back

No personal Gain: no back door cycle of any personal gain.

And possibly get a very small amount of experience point (supercell can decide the numbers)

Can be played either offline or online..

What do you guys think?!?!?! or Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down, give reason why!!!!

Thank you !

[charizzle]

This has been asked so many times, and the same reasoning for why it shouldn't has also been given so many times. In short, war comes, your friend copies an enemies base down as his own, you attack him over and over to practice a near perfect 3 star.

[klofroNNorfolk]

Rated this thread a 1 star. It's not a idea that will be implemented. Want practice? Then use a army on a base that you can attack.

[jzitovsky]

This has been asked so many times, and the same reasoning for why it shouldn't has also been given so many times. In short, war comes, your friend copies an enemies base down as his own, you attack him over and over to practice a near perfect 3 star.

They can always disable tbe feature during war? Although then theres revenge...

[GameSketcher]

who wouldn't want to attack there own clan members… anyone agree or disagree?

Rules: No Personal Gain, just pure friendly attack on your clan members.

Troops bought will determine how much elixir is given back by the stars you earn from your friendly attack.

1 Star: 1/3 of elixir given back
2 Star: 1/2 of elixir given back
3 Star: Everything is given back

No personal Gain: no back door cycle of any personal gain.

And possibly get a very small amount of experience point (supercell can decide the numbers)

Can be played either offline or online..

What do you guys think?!?!?! or Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down, give reason why!!!!

Thank you !

Sorry, but WT* is this??!
It's so bad idea...

[stephenSpk]

This has been asked so many times, and the same reasoning for why it shouldn't has also been given so many times. In short, war comes, your friend copies an enemies base down as his own, you attack him over and over to practice a near perfect 3 star.

is that why my rating was one? i didn't know this was asked multiple times… the variables of people wanting to attack just to practice on a enemy base seem unrealistic for 24hrs for prep time? To bad this idea won't happen. Thank you !

[stephenSpk]

Rated this thread a 1 star. It's not a idea that will be implemented. Want practice? Then use a army on a base that you can attack.

other people wanted practice for the same reason copy base then attack to get a perfect 3 star, my cause is just strictly for fun everyone is so competitive on clan wars..

if there wasn't a clan war would this idea be great?

[rwelshjr]

This has been asked so many times, and the same reasoning for why it shouldn't has also been given so many times. In short, war comes, your friend copies an enemies base down as his own, you attack him over and over to practice a near perfect 3 star.

This is correct, and you are right it would be a problem. But if they made the feature unavailable during war that problem goes away.

My whole clan wants to attack my base and I would love to let them it would be so fun. So I agree with the problems but hope they overcome them to make this possible. (Its on their 'under consideration' list anyhow. For whatever that is worth, not sure its much tbh)