War surrender and automatic win

[ashrafbokhari]

It would be nice if clan leader can surrender and declare defeat after 12 hours if he sees that his clan cannot win. Also would be nice if 2 clans in war that who gets full stars first is considered automatic win without waiting for 24 Hours to pass.

[legoman249]

Why would anyone want this? Why are you even suggesting this?

[ashrafbokhari]

Why would anyone want this? Why are you even suggesting this?

It is done to save time and start another war better than loosing and having to wait 24 hours for that

[legoman249]

So its to prevent the shame of losing?

[jaysonschwinn]

My problem with it is that it robs the opposing clan the opportunity to earn clan xp and war bonuses from the clan that is giving up.

And why are you giving up? Go earn some clan xp, get your members (albeit limited) loot and determine how to do better next time.

[ashrafbokhari]

So its to prevent the shame of losing?

If i get full stars i want to move on to next war. If i am loosing yes i want to get it over with and move on.

[ironagedave]

If i get full stars i want to move on to next war. If i am loosing yes i want to get it over with and move on.

does everybody in your clan feel the same way I think not - who gets to decide, the leader? this could single handedly destroy clans because people think different.

And what about the chance to maximise your consolation loot for time and troops used up? And your XPs and what about the opposition clan all just because you want to end the war early.

[ElfLiya]

humiliation button, this can be explioted for trolling

[ashrafbokhari]

does everybody in your clan feel the same way I think not - who gets to decide, the leader? this could single handedly destroy clans because people think different.

And what about the chance to maximise your consolation loot for time and troops used up? And your XPs and what about the opposition clan all just because you want to end the war early.

Yes i see your point its the leader who decides. However a good leader would seek clan benefit not individuals benefit... if you are leader you would know that sometimes should cut your losses and move on.

[edomingox]

Yes i see your point its the leader who decides. However a good leader would seek clan benefit not individuals benefit... if you are leader you would know that sometimes should cut your losses and move on.

A good leader would not "cut their losses". A good leader will tell the rest of the clan to make their attacks to get their bonus rather than quit it early and have people lose their attacks.

I don't think there is any rationale that would make this a good idea.