The solution to war hoppers starts and ends with clan leadership. It is not SC responsibilty to prop up poor management skills.
This debate is pointless.
No amount of statistics will show intent.
No amount of statistics will improve a poor leadership decision.
No amount of statistics will ensure that hoppers will be discouraged.
Penalising people automatically is unfair and unwarranted.
The solution starts with recognizing the real.problem at hand...leaders taking untrusted people into CW.
Solutions are only for problems, I don't see a problem. My clan and many others do not have a problem with hoppers. The solution would be to actually listen to peoples advice and manage your clan better. When somebody joins you could make them sit out the first war, or ask them if they intend to war.
If you think this section of the forum is just for SC staff, then you need to read the stickies.
Here is one for you (read tip #3):http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...etting-Started