View Poll Results: Should this be implemented?

Voters
1049. You may not vote on this poll
  • I love it! Should be implemented right away!

    798 76.07%
  • Awesome but needs some work (Specify in a comment)

    149 14.20%
  • No this should not be implemented (Specify in a comment)

    102 9.72%
Page 1 of 67 1231151 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 667

Thread: Clan [Troop] Bank

  1. #1
    Forum Elder Kowalski711's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Officially Retired: Yes I'm alive :smirk:
    Posts
    2,932

    Talking Clan [Troop] Bank



    **THIS IS NOT RULED OUT - THE RULED OUT VERSION IS FOR RESOURCES, NOT TROOPS


    Quote Originally Posted by twister
    Currently Ruled Out:

    Frequently Requested:
    *Donating (or trading) resources or gems to (with) other players

    Too long don't want to read summary:
    The Clan [Troop] Bank is a place for a clan to store donation only troops.

    If you don't know what to comment but you like the idea, just say bump 10char for me.

    Shoutout to devil for putting this in his sticky!!!
    Make sure you check this thread out too!
    http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ositions-Roles
    make sure to check out my FC!
    http://tinyurl.com/qc26qx9


    The Problem
    Currently only online clan members can donate to you. As a result, if you are on late at night, or early in the morning about to raid, you can't get any CC troops because nobody is online! This means you might be in danger of losing an attack or defense!


    The Solution
    If you REALLY need a troop donation and nobody is online, why not have a way to still get troops? A clan bank! This clan bank can contain troops that were donated to the clan. When you need troops, you can simply open the clan bank and take what you need.


    Please note, the clan bank WILL NOT CONTAIN ELIXIR, GOLD, OR DARK ELIXIR


    Bank Basics
    The Clan [Troop] Bank is unlocked at clan perks level 2. It is a bank to store troops, and only troops. The Bank can be turned on/off. As your clan perks lvl increases so does the amount of troops the bank can hold. Whenever someone donates to the bank a clan message will appear simply saying “_____ has donated x amount of (level)(troop)s.” And likewise when someone removes troops “_____ has withdrawn x amount of (level)(troop)s.” <---- This is all stored in a log like the clan war log. The log contains all clan member names and how many they've donated as well as received.


    Clan and Player Requirements
    By default, one needs to have the "new" rank go away (A 7 day period).
    This option is changeable by clan leadership so that it requires a rank.


    Clan Bank Specs
    The bank CAN, I repeat CAN get full of troops.
    Keep in mind, a leader CAN remove bad troops from the clan bank like goblins. When you donate or take a troop from the clan bank, you troop received or donated amount will go up.


    Lv 1 Clan: N/A
    Lv 2 Clan: 50 troops
    Lv 3 Clan: 100 troops
    Lv 4 Clan: 150 troops
    Lv 5 Clan: 200 troops
    Lv 6 Clan: 250 troops
    Lv 7 Clan: 300 troops
    Lv 8 Clan: 350 troops
    Lv 9 Clan: 400 troops
    Lv 10 Clan: 450 troops


    TROOPS GO DIRECTLY TO YOUR CLAN CASTLE, NOT YOUR ARMY CAMPS!!!


    Anti-Hopper/Leecher Precautions
    Anti-Hopper features include the “new” rank going away.
    Anti-Leecher features include the need for the leader to set a minimum donation per troop received level, or a given:taken troop ratio.This may sound confusing but let me explain.


    Leecher ( let's call him bob)


    Bob has to donate 100 troops to the bank to receive 75 troops. Of course, this number can be changed by the leader, but this would just be the default setting. The leader could just simply tap a button to change this to, let's say, 50 donated for 30 troops received. Do note that the leader can also specify what level the troops must be, that way nobody donates lvl 1 goblins.


    Clan [War] Bank
    For a clan war the same type of concept is used. People donate to a pool of (Maximum of 5 donations per member, unless your clan perk says otherwise) donations, these donations can be taken for ONLY war requests. Any remaining troops will be sent to the clan bank.


    Donation Count
    One will donate to the bank, but their donation count will not go up. Why you ask? To prevent an influx of 1. X.P. and 2. False donation numbers.
    After your troop is received, or someone takes it from the bank, your donation count goes up, and you receive your X.P.
    To prevent crazy donation numbers, your donation amount (let's say 30 troops) is split in half to a total of 15 and if you donated an odd number, that decimal is rounded up, e.g. 31 = 15.5, or 16.


    Interface
    **Photos will provide a better explanation
    If a Lvl 1 drag is donated, and then another drag any lvl above 1 is donated, a little blue box with a star will appear in the edge of the dragon image. You tap on this star and it will show you all the levels of that troop available to take.


    To counter this:


    Quote Originally Posted by dahimi View Post
    Step 1: Donate to bank.
    Step 2: Retrieve from bank.
    Step 3: Profit.

    You won't see the troop you just donated to the bank. Ex. No dragons are in the bank, you donate a dragon, however you don't see one, then once someone else donates a dragon, theirs shows up.


    Thanks
    ~Kowalski711


    ANY FEEDBACK AND CONSTRUCTIVE
    CRITICISM IS WELCOMED!!!
    NOTE: This thread is not to tell me to get a better clan etc - My clan is extremely active, our donors average 1000+ troops per season. This idea is to help players when their m8s aren't online, but they themselves are!
    And don't forget to vote in the poll! Thanks Anthony for the amazing pic!!!! 19,824~ views and 366 replies :0


    Oh and the leaf blower joke was started by me.


    Other Ideas:
    http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...11-s-Idea-List


    Old thread:
    http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...7849-Clan-Bank
    Last edited by Kowalski711; June 24th, 2016 at 03:27 PM. Reason: Finally changed it :D

    Fan Club|Ideas|Sticky W/ Reasons|About Me|Clan Troop Bank
    Quote Originally Posted by ztb29 View Post
    Nuke has killer in his name while Kowalski is a killer of ideas in IFR...
    Quote Originally Posted by iPromise View Post
    [You're famous for being] That guy who was once a GASP, but now just floats around dropping his minion poo on poo ideas in Ideas & Feature Requests.

  2. #2
    Forum Elder Kowalski711's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Officially Retired: Yes I'm alive :smirk:
    Posts
    2,932
    Photos provided by Hairich





    I got got these photos from a different thread, so replace the words "Troop/Donation Box" Clan [Troop] Bank.
    Thanks!
    Last edited by Kowalski711; May 28th, 2015 at 01:26 PM. Reason: Photos

    Fan Club|Ideas|Sticky W/ Reasons|About Me|Clan Troop Bank
    Quote Originally Posted by ztb29 View Post
    Nuke has killer in his name while Kowalski is a killer of ideas in IFR...
    Quote Originally Posted by iPromise View Post
    [You're famous for being] That guy who was once a GASP, but now just floats around dropping his minion poo on poo ideas in Ideas & Feature Requests.

  3. #3
    Senior Member Json8r's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    U.S.A
    Posts
    348
    No, this ruins the purpose of having to have people on right then. Also open to abuse by hoppers.
    CLASH ONNN!!! TH: 8 Level: 57(wow that's low). CLAN: BikeKingz #9COP9RRG Goblin Guide
    Quote Originally Posted by rwelshjr View Post
    I think it would be better to drag them outside, strip them naked, and bury them in an anthill. With honey all over them.

    MOST NEEDED FEATURE:Mastermind's quest ideas Here MOST NEEDED FIX:No default troop

  4. #4
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2014
    Posts
    95

    Like it

    This would be awesome if the clan bank storage was increased by the level of your clan! Also, hoppers could be prevented by only letting Elder+ take troops!!!

  5. #5
    Forum Elder Kowalski711's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Officially Retired: Yes I'm alive :smirk:
    Posts
    2,932
    Quote Originally Posted by Json8r View Post
    No, this ruins the purpose of having to have people on right then. Also open to abuse by hoppers.
    1. No it doesn't ruin having people on
    2. You have to have the "new" rank disappear and a rank

    Fan Club|Ideas|Sticky W/ Reasons|About Me|Clan Troop Bank
    Quote Originally Posted by ztb29 View Post
    Nuke has killer in his name while Kowalski is a killer of ideas in IFR...
    Quote Originally Posted by iPromise View Post
    [You're famous for being] That guy who was once a GASP, but now just floats around dropping his minion poo on poo ideas in Ideas & Feature Requests.

  6. #6
    Forum Elder Kowalski711's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Officially Retired: Yes I'm alive :smirk:
    Posts
    2,932
    Quote Originally Posted by NF2335 View Post
    No point in making it only elder+
    If it only members with a 'new' status can't access the clan bank, then hoppers can't exploit it (which is already in the OP's idea).
    I made it elder+ just for some trust from the leaders

    Fan Club|Ideas|Sticky W/ Reasons|About Me|Clan Troop Bank
    Quote Originally Posted by ztb29 View Post
    Nuke has killer in his name while Kowalski is a killer of ideas in IFR...
    Quote Originally Posted by iPromise View Post
    [You're famous for being] That guy who was once a GASP, but now just floats around dropping his minion poo on poo ideas in Ideas & Feature Requests.

  7. #7
    Forum Elder Kowalski711's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Officially Retired: Yes I'm alive :smirk:
    Posts
    2,932
    Feedback anyone?

    Fan Club|Ideas|Sticky W/ Reasons|About Me|Clan Troop Bank
    Quote Originally Posted by ztb29 View Post
    Nuke has killer in his name while Kowalski is a killer of ideas in IFR...
    Quote Originally Posted by iPromise View Post
    [You're famous for being] That guy who was once a GASP, but now just floats around dropping his minion poo on poo ideas in Ideas & Feature Requests.

  8. #8
    This is a great idea I'd love if they Woul make this a thing

  9. #9
    Forum Elder Kowalski711's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Officially Retired: Yes I'm alive :smirk:
    Posts
    2,932
    Quote Originally Posted by Thewizz8910 View Post
    This is a great idea I'd love if they Woul make this a thing
    Thanks for the feedback and support

    Fan Club|Ideas|Sticky W/ Reasons|About Me|Clan Troop Bank
    Quote Originally Posted by ztb29 View Post
    Nuke has killer in his name while Kowalski is a killer of ideas in IFR...
    Quote Originally Posted by iPromise View Post
    [You're famous for being] That guy who was once a GASP, but now just floats around dropping his minion poo on poo ideas in Ideas & Feature Requests.

  10. #10
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Posts
    347
    would be a great idea and might help stop people from hopping. that said i think that this would be a great thing to add to the clan perks. ei unlocked at lvl 3 can hold 50 troops spaces lvl 5 75 troop spaces ect. also lvl 4 donate up to 5 troops a day lvl 6 6 troops ect or just have it be the same as the troops able to donate

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •