Option to recognize HOPPERS!

[LudogoretsRazgrad]

These so called "Hoppers" are limitless. They keep on hopping from clan to clan,for no reason. WHY NOT just find a clan,and STAY there? There aren't clans with naked girls in it. I'm almost maxed Town Hall 9 (110 Level) and since I started playing the game,I had only 2 clans,and I left my first,because the leader had a car accident,and all the clan members,got rebelled,and left that clan. Since that,I found great people,offered them to make ourselves a clan,and everything works perfectly,except those hoppers. Something definitely should be done about them. It's really annoying to leave,when the war is about to start

So my suggestion is:

A new feature (maybe a button)that will be held in every player's profile,which will Enable/Disable that player from joining this clan ever again. That button,should be used and visible only by the clan leaders.

For Example:

As a Leader,Logging into my clan,and see a player left for no reason,in a middle of a war. Then I'm going in his profile,and clicking Disable. This player will never be able to log into our clan again,until I re-click again,to be Enabled.

- There are lots of ways,to be made to recognize hoppers,like their nickname to be changed to a different color,only visible to the leaders,and when the hopper log on,to be removed immediately... and probably much more options to be think of,but I suggest only this

[UndeadZombie]

I'm sorry about your leader's incident but this feature would be cool

[TheUsAsian]

interesting idea
Hmmm

[useless]

hoppers are players like as so leave them alone


heres how to deal with them

1-dont give troops to new members

2-dont make new members join the first war (hoppers will leave)

[LudogoretsRazgrad]

hoppers are players like as so leave them alone


heres how to deal with them

1-dont give troops to new members

2-dont make new members join the first war (hoppers will leave)

1. There isn't an option to remove the request,except by filling it.

2. Yesterday,we started a clan war search,and the hopper left the clan,when we found an opponent. It was the second war,since he was in.

They are doing it on purpose,so can not spend elexir.

[useless]

1. There isn't an option to remove the request,except by filling it.

2. Yesterday,we started a clan war search,and the hopper left the clan,when we found an opponent. It was the second war,since he was in.

They are doing it on purpose,so can not spend elexir.

dont make new players join the war thats it hoppers will leave by 99% before the next war (if he did not leave until he join a war then its kinda personal)

[Siddmaster]

Hoppers are simple trying to join a clan that fits them, donating troops for exp/FIN, or just joining and leaving for the fun of it. If they request and leave that just means more donations for your clan and more exp for you. So no.

[HydroPenguin]

This would be a bad idea due to server overload because of database of specific list of people disabled for that clan.

Imagine that one player has restrictions on many clans. Let's say... We multiply this guy by 200k... Do you think Supercells server can handle that?

[WarrenJames]

This is close to the ban list in other threads.

My suggestion.. wait.. should just quote.

Ban list would be good for those bots that come by and leave. Or that person that you kick, and sneaks back on.

Would give an expiration on the ban, just out of practically. Say maybe a week or a month. Because after awhile, the list will have names that aren't needed anymore, since a banned person would have long got the message, and hopefully the bot would gone by then.

Have experience with online text games and whatnot, and have lists of things, mostly friends list, that are mostly useless because people have come and gone. So it makes sense to me to have the list self clean after while, just for management sake.

There we are!

You can click the to go to the original ban list idea thread.

[rwelshjr]

Your idea for hopper stats at the bottom needs to be put aside since that is against SC policy to post negative stats. And also there are giuys that would unfairly earn high hopper numbers because of how they move between feeds, freand's clans, and Req clans (just to give 3 examples) . But your idea of blocking the player has merit. It is indeed a variation of the ban list idea that quite a few guys have put here. I don't think it will help with hoppers much but would be handy for guys that are repeat offenders for really any sort of problem. (cussers, trolls, etc..)

So I hope they do adopt your idea but here is some additional things you can do not to avoid hoppers but to avoid getting hurt by them.

1. Always make guys donate first. And if they like give 5 archers and request a dragon, give 5 archers back. Tell them nicely that to get higher level they have to give that.
2. If they give like one or two barbs or archers then request kick immediately. They are looking to give the minimum before getting stuff which tells you all you need about them.
3. Have a policy that until 50 (or some say 100) donations an even to positive ratio needs to be maintained at all times. If they are breaking that no need to get argumentative. Just don't give and if they ask why say so nicely.
4. If they show up and ask for elder kick immediately. No need to respond or say anything. Just go right to the button.
5. If even after a short while talk at all about need a promotion to stay just kick. Again, no need to comment, hit button.
6. If they start talking about needing to feel trusted tell them that they are not and if they can't live with that then they should go. Or if you don't feel like that much typing just kick.
7. Whenever anyone joins opt them out of the first war to start after they join (if they join at any time during one opt out of the next.

Some or all of these thongs are going to cost you some guys. But that's actually good because those were guys that were going to do you no good anyhow. It will also help you retain the quality players because most of those are smart enough to understand what they are seeing and that it means they will have to endure less nonsense from guys if they stay with your clan.

Don't worry if these measures mean your clan is not filling as fast. Getting quality over quantity will ultimately grow you faster and also will be easier on your soul and less demanding on your leadership effort.