Clan Hopper Jumping deterrent- SIMPLE WAY: Player History button

[RockyJoeHawkins]

Amazing idea.

[kyleksq]

Another great idea supercell didn't bother to implement. No money in it for them i guess.

First- Why on earth did you necro a 17 month old thread? Ironic for someone with the name "NewUpdate*****etc"

Second- This idea is ruled out.

Third- You daftly saying "there's no money in it" implies adding this feature would generate profit for SC?I'm beside myself in anticipation to hear you elaborate on how this would be possible.

Fourth and Lastly- This would penalize players in a negative manner who have friends in other clans, or have multiple clans in a group (feeders). Its an unfair measuring stick that would only result in falsely labeling players. A great "clan hopper deterrent" would be common sense. Look at FIN and War stars as the two best means to determine the quality of a player before letting them into your clan. And if you're in doubt REJECT....

Mod- Please close this garbage thread.

[MATHSTER]

A gazillion stars for this

[paulting]

Nice. but at some point the history would have to over flow.

yeah you do have to flow with things, i dont mind if members consatntly leave or come back, they just wont get appointed elder

[iansilv]

Thanks for the feedback everybody. Despite what was posted above by a "senior member", this idea has not been ruled out and would not unfairly penalize players. It would just be a solid way to:

1. Discourage obnoxious clan hopping, like when someone hits for loot and leaves mid war, and

2. Tell whether a player is honest in their communications about their commitment to the clan they are joining, in so much as the clan they are jointing values it.

Basically, like a COC credit report...

Also, this is not a "dead thread". A dead thread is one where the issue has been answered or addressed somewhere else. This suggestion has not been fully implemented, nor has it been addressed or ruled out.

[isaactan999]

I would consider making it simpler, where the menu only shows the last clans the guy has been to in a 7d history, with the time showing only accurate to 12h, so if the guy was in a clangay♥♥♥s69) 35h ago it will register as 1 day, and not 1d12h. And is he was in that clan 6h ago it will not show up in log, and if he visits multiple clans in 6 hours and it passes the 12h mark they are all classified under 12h. sorry if this sounds stupid, was thinking of supercell and their servers, it would be hard to add everything on the list lol :P

[ClasherTimothy123]

Hopping has been a problem in my clan for a while, but now if this was implemented we would have a lot more members. Before we accept a request, we look at their profile, and now, their clan history!

[Vasude]

5 stars...
u solved another problem, war spying.

no more spys!!

[Monkton]

Nice idea, I'd like to use it as an option to filter new clan members. I find Hopper-Droppers, people who join my clan to drop Giants and Barbs/Gobs on all requests for cheap exp, before hopping to the next clan the biggest problem now. We seem to get more of these "players" than people who play the game. Just keeping a running count of the number of new clans someone has joined in a season, or left/booted, with an option to not allow anyone new above a certain number would really improve the game in my opinion. This would also not stop people hanging around in a group of clans if that's what they like.

[TheOneTheyCallSmasher]

I think it should only show clans you have been in the past week or something, like battle logs. If you are constantly hopping, you would only need to see the past week to know if you are hopping or not.

Also, a "dead" thread is any thread where people are not posting. This thread was dead before it was necro'd