Fix Clan Perks System as its totally unfair right Now!

[Matey]

When i read the title, i instantly disagreed., when i added my vote, i saw the community disagreed with the title.


91% of people to leave it the way it is.

Im not going through the other replies but the OP needs to stop whining.

[vincentboy]

how about this?

if you fail in an offensive raid, the amount of resources in your storages are cut by the amount of available loot in the offesnsive raid you just lost.

seems fair?


My clan win 8-9 out of 10 wars, and yet i think this idea is stupid.

in fact, most forumers here are war winners as most forumers are hardcore player, yet the poll shows what it shows.

[petio1981]

Hello SuperCell,I really liked the concept of clan perks but there is one and only negative to it that needs to be fixed asap!I know winning clans getting level up soon but loosing clans also leveling up after 1 or 2 more wars compared to winning one.For example a winning clan can get upto lvl2 in 3 wars and loosing clans will get uped to lvl2 in 4 wars. so this system is totally unfair to the winning clans.kindly adjust the system and do something like give negative xp to loosing clan so they go lvl down or give no xp if they loose war.like u give xp in the end for winning war, make another tag like -100% for loosing war.got me? kindly vote guys who agree to it!Thank you for such a great game!

Why all the hate...???

[Alex78]

No it's not unfair, clan wars matchmaking is also based on the clan level, you will never be placed against a different level clan, tested it. If you lose a clan war you should not be awarded extra XP, because you simply don't deserve it and you don't deserve being the same level as a very skilled war clan, it would be unfair to them.

[iDANglin]

Hello SuperCell,I really liked the concept of clan perks but there is one and only negative to it that needs to be fixed asap!I know winning clans getting level up soon but loosing clans also leveling up after 1 or 2 more wars compared to winning one.For example a winning clan can get upto lvl2 in 3 wars and loosing clans will get uped to lvl2 in 4 wars. so this system is totally unfair to the winning clans.kindly adjust the system and do something like give negative xp to loosing clan so they go lvl down or give no xp if they loose war.like u give xp in the end for winning war, make another tag like -100% for loosing war.got me? kindly vote guys who agree to it!Thank you for such a great game!

Congrats. Everybody disagrees with you.

[WarrenJames]

The point is this, the team effort is what gets you clan xp. You are working as a team to better yourselves. Not every clan is going to win every war, but every clan can benefit and learn from a loss.

Totaly agree (rest of quotes are cherry picked examples of what I agree with)

The system appears to be doing well in encouraging clans to fight to the finish in order to maximise experience. My clan has won all of its wars since the update and I have no problem with our opponents getting points. They have deserved them.

I can now make the excuse of 'keep on fighting' because of the XP system, even if badly out matched.

I think what the OP is saying:


"It's not enough that I succeed, others should fail"

Yeah, sounds a bit vindictive..

They are called experience points. Not win points. Even if you lose you still gain experience. Regardless the best argument is the poll results.

Lol negative xp? One of the worst ideas I've seen in a long time.

Ever played D&D before (3.5 Ed and older)? There are effects that cause level loss (aka XP loss). Players have been known to rather let thier developed character die that be left behind level-wise, and roll up a new one at the same level as the rest. So yea, negative XP is worse than death at times.

OP you sound like a whining child throwing your toys out of the pram.

Losing a war already nets you less xp than winning a war. it takes a bout a year for an always winnig clan t get to level 10 they say....so if you lose every once i a while and get xp deducted your clan will never get there...whats the incentice then?

you didnt think your agrument through and frankly the only one who would have a mindset like this ' its not fair...wah wah wah' are children who tend to not be able to understand the bigger picture.

Considerig you made an account to start this thread... I conclude you are either a troll or a child.

Clash on mate, enjoy, dont envy the others so much and keep off forum ok

There is a good point for you OP. Losers already are out 50 XP for not winning, or did you forget that?

Erm. XP = Experience Points

Win or lose, you are suppose to learn.

Or else, CW will be dominated by clans of uber (x) users. U wanna see that?

They are called EXPERIENCE points, not winning points.

To award zero experience points implies that the clan did not experience war.

Sound logic to me.

Congrats. Everybody disagrees with you.

Ouch, yeah, look at the votes...

@#$% Dude! Your @#$%#$% poll! @#$% you OP! I wish I got ½ that kind of turn out on the more important issues I post on this forum! Why the @#$% do you get all the attention when my stuff gets ignored!?
(censored cussing partly done out of humor and not in a serious intent)

---

Added edit: Forgot to say that the perks add very little, if anything to the overall strength of a clan in a clan war. Maybe, maybe, the level boost of troops may help, but by the time you get that far, your clan will likely already have a few people with maxed troops, or close to it. It took me from Mid October to now to get to Mid state TH8! What would a year mean for most people in a clan? Yup, many TH9s and TH10s. New low level clans fighting a high level old clan? Will never happen unless the old clan is gutted of it's old members or has people that barely develop, or the new clan is made of already developed villages. Even then, war bonus increase, war loot storage increase, and reduced CC cool down times are not going to be major factors in wining. Even a +1 or +2 level boost in CC troops isn't something we don't see already with one TH Rushed base giving high level troops to everyone. And like that extra level or two means they are unkillable. Just means now others don't have to rely on some TH rushed troop warlord to give them that edge.

[ShaneHed13]

If dude says XP Points one more time, I might freak out.

XP = Experience Points
XP Points = Experience Points Points

[WarrenJames]

If dude says XP Points one more time, I might freak out.

XP = Experience Points
XP Points = Experience Points Points

They could argue "eXPerience" Points.

But yeah, I get what you mean. Like saying ATM machine (Automatic Teller Machine) machine. ...

Hi Hello, Bureau Department Office of Backup Auxiliary Redundancies. How can I help you? Anything I can help you with? This is the Bureau Department Office of Backup Auxiliary Redundancies speaking.

[dahimi]

If dude says XP Points one more time, I might freak out.

XP = Experience Points
XP Points = Experience Points Points

I went to the ATM machine and they asked me for my PIN number.

[Medici]

It's not broken so no need to fix it.