I have already said things that are very true about your idea. Do you want me to continue to talk about and discuss the parts of your Idea that make it really bad?Originally Posted by AnthonyVince
I have already said things that are very true about your idea. Do you want me to continue to talk about and discuss the parts of your Idea that make it really bad?
No, he want's constructive criticism on how to make the idea better. Either that, or, since you've already said you like it, say nothing. At least that's what I think he meant.
My best threads: The Overseer, Flying Shark,Shockwave Spell, Empusa, FLAMEingo
Do you want me to continue to talk about and discuss the parts of your personality that make it really bad?
That is not quite the On-Topic he would of wanted. Talking and discussing what the really bad parts of the Idea is, that could make the Idea better.
When did I say that I liked it?
My bad, misread your comment. You said true, not positive.When did I say that I liked it?
My best threads: The Overseer, Flying Shark,Shockwave Spell, Empusa, FLAMEingo
I think you should take out the part about it following the pack and slowing down for slower units so deployment of when and where becomes more of a factor. I think it would increase the strategy behind the unit. Imo anyway. Other than that I don't see many problems with it.Thank you. I appreciate that (I hope) you like my idea.
Yes, I know this would only slightly improve tier 1 troops, but since these kinds of troops (most noticeably Barch) are usually packed, the damage boost will be slightly more noticeable. But yes, it is definitely not ideal to incorporate the Volcano Mage into your farming strategy.
Secondly, I know this would overpower higher troops, but that is the point of this unit. Since he doesn't work well with lower troops, it's only fair he would do more effect on higher troops. I kept the Wizard, PEKKA, Giant, and Barbarian King in mind while creating this because I know that people use these a lot and this would greatly improve war attacks at higher levels.
Thank you for your feedback, and I would be glad if you would like to know anything else!
Ps I did the math on hp and damage. Not sure it overpowers higher tier troops too bad especially for max th9 and 10 bases
While I do agree that this would make more strategy, doing this would make the troop terribly underused and underpowered, because the Volcano Mage could just wander off on his own. I want his AI to be like the Healer, and there's already strategy on where to deploy him because he has low hit points.
And thanks, good to know this troop wouldn't terribly overpower high tier troops.
All troops wander with the exception of the healer. But the healer is targeted by the AD's which counteract the fact that the other defenses will be targeting the troops ahead of her. No def building specifically targets the VM so even with low hp he would follow the tankier troops not taking any damage while providing them with damage boost the entire attack. There's zero strategy in deploying him because he's made to follow and as you pretty much said is designed more for higher tier troops (lower tier troops atleast have low hp where the can be killed off making him vulnerable), most noticably the pekka, golem (which usually has wiz behind him too) or heroes. I think that's where he might become overpowered because he is designed in such a way that deployment of him doesn't really matter.
Last edited by Maduro25; April 26th, 2015 at 05:08 PM.
When did I say that I liked it?
Over half the replies in your "idea" were your replies.
///
In relation to the idea, I like it.
Posting Permissions
