Clan Deserter Punishment

[PSRumors]

Clan Hoppers and deserters are a real nuisance to Clashers. We should be able to find and attack any Hopper or Clan Deserter that leaves his or her clan, especially during war. The punishment would be, a deserter leaves your clan, you get to have any 3 of your fellow clan mates to attack the deserter 1 time each over the next week. Shields would not apply to the deserter, since they must be punished.

This would not totally eliminate the constant Hoppers or frequent clan deserters, but would give some satisfaction to an otherwise frustrated clan. And the deserter or hopper would receive the wrath they so richly deserve.

[Json8r]

No, this idea is rediculous

[Lyle44]

Clan Hoppers and deserters are a real nuisance to Clashers. We should be able to find and attack any Hopper or Clan Deserter that leaves his or her clan, especially during war. The punishment would be, a deserter leaves your clan, you get to have any 3 of your fellow clan mates to attack the deserter 1 time each over the next week. Shields would not apply to the deserter, since they must be punished.

This would not totally eliminate the constant Hoppers or frequent clan deserters, but would give some satisfaction to an otherwise frustrated clan. And the deserter or hopper would receive the wrath they so richly deserve.

THIS NEEDS TO BE IN THE GAME!!!

Really? think this through bud.
this is the most idiotic idea i have read. Don't be mad because nobody wants to stay in your clan.

[ColonelAwesome]

so basically you just want another sad excuse to get free loot from people? If this were ever somehow implemented, I guarantee that 95% of the time people would use those attacks on others who did nothing wrong.

[victort]

Absurd!..... hoppers are a nuisance, but invite only helps.... war deserters, so what?.... Their base still defends, and you make the 2 attacks up....

Under your suggestion, anyone is punished for leaving a clan!..... If it's such a problem, perhaps you need to run your clan better, and be stricter with who you let in, or include in wars.....

[TimothyH97]

I have never left anyone during a war. but I hop into TONS of clans and donate then leave. By you're rule, I could get like 100 people attacking me with 10 minutes of donating and hopping around.

a better solution to your prob is
----------------
use invite only or closed
make the 'random' people stay X amount of time before they war with you
(our rule is two wars or one week which ever one is shorter)

[rwelshjr]

THIS NEEDS TO BE IN THE GAME!!!

Really? think this through bud.
this is the most idiotic idea i have read. Don't be mad because nobody wants to stay in your clan.

I think it would be better to drag them outside, strip them naked, and bury them in an anthill. With honey all over them.

[Json8r]

Thats going im my sig

I think it would be better to drag them outside, strip them naked, and bury them in an anthill. With honey all over them.