Clan wars opt in or out feature

[Dennsal]

Have the badge gray not green, if a clan member has not made a choice to participate in a clan war. I want to only take members into war that want to go to war and attack. As it stands now, there still is no real way of knowing if a member wants to fight if his badge is green.

[Phil01274]

Green in, red out, hardly rocket science

[DARWINIANS]

Have the badge gray not green, if a clan member has not made a choice to participate in a clan war. I want to only take members into war that want to go to war and attack. As it stands now, there still is no real way of knowing if a member wants to fight if his badge is green.

Green in, red out, hardly rocket science

Green = IN
Red = OUT

But the Leader/Co-leader can still add you in the war even when you're opting out.

[Dennsal]

Green in, red out, hardly rocket science

A neutral color until a choice is made is not rocket science either!

[FireThief]

Have the badge gray not green, if a clan member has not made a choice to participate in a clan war. I want to only take members into war that want to go to war and attack. As it stands now, there still is no real way of knowing if a member wants to fight if his badge is green.

It does not need to be changed- its fine.

[rwelshjr]

The OP has no credibility here. he is just playing games. Check where he started the same debate in the Clan Wars forum.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-feature/page2


Below is the feedback on his other thread. its true of this one too...

The two choices should be in or out. I think it is ridiculous to try and have a third choice. In fact, when going to war what the heck would you do with those guys? (If you answer hold them out then I say they should be red not gray, if you say put them in then I say they should be green not gray)

Or is it that the clan is not supposed to be allowed to declare ware with the unresolved questions?

No matter how you slice it this is not a conversation that makes sense.

[TimothyH97]

Do you want it on the Rosetta Stone???? Would it help if we got Einstein to spell it out in a mathematical formula?? Red is out. Green is in....this is really tough stuff were dealing with here. Im amazed at the apparent inability to interpret this color-coded concept, by more than one person.

[WarrenJames]

OK, here to complicate the issue.

OP is half on a good idea, but thier reason for a third setting is rather... off.

Personally, I'd like a "Don't Care" neutral setting (not OP's "Don't Know" setting). That way when your member count is in an awkward state, you have buffer of people you can opt in or out, and you know for a fact they aren't going to pitch a fit for being forced in, or left out of a war.

[trooperc007]

Have the badge gray not green, if a clan member has not made a choice to participate in a clan war. I want to only take members into war that want to go to war and attack. As it stands now, there still is no real way of knowing if a member wants to fight if his badge is green.

Haven't you ever seen a stop light before?

[WarrenJames]

Haven't you ever seen a stop light before?

Green = Opt In
Yellow = Either
Red = Opt Out

Brilliant!


Maybe I should make my own thread with this better idea. Because I could use an Either-or Opt in/out setting.