War Clan Castles Donations

[QueenJamalama]

I think donations made for the war clan castles should count toward the player's personal donations. There are some players that don't donate to war clan castles, and some do a lot. This would allow recognition for those players that donate. I also think this would motivate players to donate more and higher level troops. War does require higher troops for defense, but if players were given the recognition (by counting it toward their personal donations), it would take less pressure off the leaders and co leaders to always donate and give up thier resources.
Keep in mind and Thanks for reading!

[IceKnight144]

it can be abused.

P1: has giants ready. donates to P2.

P2: after recieving giants, empties castle.

P1: donates giants to P2.

P2: empties castle.

repeat this process and you can have thousands of donations in just minutes.

[QueenJamalama]

That is a waste of resources. In my clan, we are very strict and keep and donate only the highest and best troops. There are rules for what to donate in war. There should be an achievement for war donations because it really is a lot of troops that go unnoticed.

[CaptainSport]

Just because YOUR clan is very strict doesn't mean others are too.

[QueenJamalama]

Yes, of course you donate to win. But sometimes it is always the same people donating over and over again. This would give an incentive for more people to donate their better troops as well.

[SouthernSoftie]

it can be abused.

P1: has giants ready. donates to P2.

P2: after recieving giants, empties castle.

P1: donates giants to P2.

P2: empties castle.

repeat this process and you can have thousands of donations in just minutes.

I have been under the impression that war castles are similar to standard donations in the respect that each player is limited to 5 donations (up to 7 with perks) regardless of if the troops got removed or not.

Should my assumption be correct I'm inclined to agree, they should award the figure and experience to the user that donated.

[QueenJamalama]

Maybe a solution then would be to penalize the player that gets rid of the perfectly good troops. In clans, there are leaders that set rules and if they want lower players to donate, then by all means, go for it. But, if the leader has said no low troops and they don't listen by donating anyway, their punishment would be a kick from the clan. So if there are troops in the war clan castle, you cannot get rid of them without being penalized (by subtracting the same amount of troops worth from your own donation count). This, then will allow the donation count to not be as easy, as well as counting war clan castle donations toward your own personal donations.