Clan War Buttons

[Quake]

Sorry for posting 2nd thread. I just made a remake of the old one.

What buttons you would like to see or not?

Here are the disscusion threads:

I'm against all of them apart from skipping prep day. I quite like the idea.

I'm all for the ready button and the end war button. However i feel like the leaders shouldn't be able to have the only say in the ready button. I can see many clan leaders finding a war and immediately saying they were ready without talking to their members and could be frustrating for someone who has an upgrade they had planned to finish during prep day.

He will finish in next war. I do wars 24/7 im used to this.


Answer to paytertot

I would say if imlimented and Ready button would have to be set for each memeber. not just the leadership or just leader. You want everyone ready for the war.

The biggest issue with this is that when one clan is all ready the other clan could wait the rest of the day timer and try to prep for the other teams bases while having fake bases set as their "war base" till the time they are ready. Thus giving them an "unfair" advantage in the war.

My personal opinion is that you have enough time to prep during the war time as it is. And if you can't figure out how to beat a base within the war time then you are not going to benifit from any extra time anyway. But the above is the argument from the other side.

In my opinion they should be added both:

Poll: END BATTLE DAY, [CW] WHEN ALL THE ATTACKS ARE CONSUMED. (Why to wait more!!!)

Poll: Ready up button for Clan Wars

I took some ideas and sum it in one poll adding some new. There was one idea of a rematch button, i cant find it where i saw it.

[Murtagh]

So forgive me if its been brought up, but people say that leaders can abuse the system and press ready before all are ready? Well I have 2 things to say. 1. If they are abusing it, the clan won't last long, and if they do last a while, its the problem of the people who aren't smart enough to leave a clan like that. and 2. If its such a big problem, then only make the "Ready" button available when all castles are full, then the leader can press ready.

I am not a huge fan of the End War option, as most people wait till the last second to attack, so I think it wouldn't be used a whole lot. I'd say only implement it if it will end war only after every single attack has been used.

In summary, I love the "Ready" button and wish for something like it every time we war. The End War button I am not a fan of because I think every second of battle day is important, though as i said if it automatically ended it once every attack was used, I'd be fine.

[btcc1721]

The issue with the ready button is:

You either extend the war day, which is fine, but then it's not really a war day is it?

Or, wars last less than 48 hours, which cannot happen, as SuperCell cannot afford the huge war payouts any more than every 48 hours. You would still have not be eligible.

I would love to see it happen, don't get me wrong, but I understand the reasons why it will never happen.

I think end war could be implemented only to get your loot earlier, but still not be eligible for war for 48 hours.

[Quake]

So forgive me if its been brought up, but people say that leaders can abuse the system and press ready before all are ready? Well I have 2 things to say. 1. If they are abusing it, the clan won't last long, and if they do last a while, its the problem of the people who aren't smart enough to leave a clan like that. and 2. If its such a big problem, then only make the "Ready" button available when all castles are full, then the leader can press ready.

I am not a huge fan of the End War option, as most people wait till the last second to attack, so I think it wouldn't be used a whole lot. I'd say only implement it if it will end war only after every single attack has been used.

In summary, I love the "Ready" button and wish for something like it every time we war. The End War button I am not a fan of because I think every second of battle day is important, though as i said if it automatically ended it once every attack was used, I'd be fine.

It could abuse, but i dont know such a foolish leader, who would try to do that.. I like my clan and dont want any mistakes or misfortunes. I always do what is the best for a clan.

about the End War button, i hope they will implent auto ending if the attacks are finished. If not, we could end this by ourselfs.

[rwelshjr]

Your forfeit button wont work. the entire war period has to stay 48 hours between bonus payouts. I know there are a lot of impatient little kids out there that have nothing else going in their lives but to stare at their screen waiting for timer to run down but they are going to have to accept the reality that its not all about their boredom. (maybe they should find something to do with the time. Self betterment is always a good thing to spend time on, especially if you have absolutely zero going on other than video games)

End of Battle I was not clear how it is different from Forfeit, but if it just means you are done and will wait for war timer to run out then its fine if anyone can think of a use for that.

Ready button is ok as long as the time off prep day gets added to battle day to keep the 48 hours. (the longer battle day also resolves a lot of the other issues with time zones, schedules, and planning that are raised against this idea)

The rematch button is awesome and I think should be offered as a one time option between 2 clans similar to revenge. Keeping it 'one time' will head off the abuses that some may be concerned about.

[Quake]

I never knew, that is strict 48hours for war. Oh well. That saves one button.

Rematch i like it too, it could be done just one time. I would love to see that in action.