War clans!!!!!!!!!!!! Idea

[bewsh1987]

The last update - war bonus and highlight that you are available for war or not……. great idea

My idea within war which is member based/war based

A member should get loyalty points
Each battle attacked
Higher base = 20 points
Level base = 10 points
Lower base number same TH level = 5 points
Lower base number lower TH level = -5 points

Leaving clan during war -20 points
Leaving Clan during War Prep -30 Points

If you have certain amount of loyalty point this goes in favour of clan bonus

This is just an idea and my levelling system could be better and broken down more I’m not going to lie, Feel free to correct me if this is an idea won’t work, as no idea is a bad idea

!!!!! I hate hoppers / Drama!!!!!!!

[Porklips]

I think this would be a great idea. This would really help against hoppers who just ask for troops and then leave.

[JHMR]

I understand you hate hoppers, I do to. But it's not a good idea. When the weaker members don't get the stars to win the war, the stronger members have to attack the weaker members to win. So the strong and loyal member gets punished for getting the winning star on a weaker opponent. Your system won't work.

[bewsh1987]

thanks for your feed back,

Totally Agree with what you are saying and this was just a base idea, but they should think about some sort of loyalty point system -

Attacking gets you points regardless of what you attack the more stars the more points if you don't attack and you say your willing to participate in green this is where you lose point as this is un-loyal

Loyal
Attack
Donate

Un-loyal
Leave
don't attack
join for war then leave (more point reduction) (prep Stage)

members who join a clan then don't speak or fight (its a little strange) yet the leader can kick which is good but they just go to another clan and do the dame.

maybe the above wont work but something has got to be done, it will be good

[rwelshjr]

Take these two out and your idea is more supportable.

Leaving clan during war -20 points
Leaving Clan during War Prep -30 Points

Those are assuming that everyone that steps out of a clan during war is a deserter, but in fact is less than half of them. So bad to punish the rest.

[AegarTargaryen]

thanks for your feed back,

Totally Agree with what you are saying and this was just a base idea, but they should think about some sort of loyalty point system -

Attacking gets you points regardless of what you attack the more stars the more points if you don't attack and you say your willing to participate in green this is where you lose point as this is un-loyal

Loyal
Attack
Donate

Un-loyal
Leave
don't attack
join for war then leave (more point reduction) (prep Stage)

members who join a clan then don't speak or fight (its a little strange) yet the leader can kick which is good but they just go to another clan and do the dame.

maybe the above wont work but something has got to be done, it will be good

I like ot. It will really help against hoppers and un loyal Clan Members.

[bewsh1987]

I think its something that can change the way people approach a war clan without it affecting the current gameplay, i want to push this idea maybe someone has already suggested it and found the pros and cons

i thought it was and idea while i was sat at my desk at work (Sad i know ), ive been in 6 clan last year which they all fell apart as the loyalty goes after time, the current clan im in are facing the same situatuion

This idea may not work when all the cons are writen down, but its sounds like a start of something in my head

"The way to get good ideas is to get lots of ideas and throw the bad ones away." - Linus Pauling

[Kowalski711]

I like it, but take out you leaving a clan. Once your clan get 16000 points and people flood in and leave in a war you will know what I mean. It would be bad to punish people in a clan who are constantly on helping the clan by taking away clan points.