Regarding Clan War

[serajim]

Hi guys,

Need your thought whether it's a good idea to have multiple scheduled wars within the clan. Since we already have the option to exclude players. Basically, there will be brackets depending on the rank and level of each member. The other groups can start their own war as long as they have a co-leader to start and select the participants. Of course the sub group must still be 10, 15, etc. as per usual.

All members who are participating the war can donate troops even if it is not their own war. Only the war group started by the main leader can gain the maximum clan experience.

Please vote if this is a good idea to be considered. Thanks!

[Ukoval]

maybe, the idea does have merit

[serajim]

This idea will promote wars for those members who are excluded due to being low level in terms of defense and troop strength. At least they can still enjoy wars in a different level.

[RoyMustang]

Hi guys,

Need your thought whether it's a good idea to have multiple scheduled wars within the clan. Since we already have the option to exclude players. Basically, there will be brackets depending on the rank and level of each member. The other groups can start their own war as long as they have a co-leader to start and select the participants. Of course the sub group must still be 10, 15, etc. as per usual.

All members who are participating the war can donate troops even if it is not their own war. Only the war group started by the main leader can gain the maximum clan experience.

Please vote if this is a good idea to be considered. Thanks!

There are a few problems with this, and all of them favor bigger clans. Most of the clans I see in clash are around 1-25 people. There are clans out there that have an abundance of people but that is beside the point. If you could segment wars, that would beef up a bigger clan's wars won, and more importantly, their clan xp. Launching multiple wars and gaining multiple bonuses would put the smaller clans at a huge disadvantage, especially when recruiting. The concept sounds interesting, but I can't see it working out fairly.

[WarriorRudy]

Quite a fair idea. But what if there aren't that many number of members ?

[serajim]

There are a few problems with this, and all of them favor bigger clans. Most of the clans I see in clash are around 1-25 people. There are clans out there that have an abundance of people but that is beside the point. If you could segment wars, that would beef up a bigger clan's wars won, and more importantly, their clan xp. Launching multiple wars and gaining multiple bonuses would put the smaller clans at a huge disadvantage, especially when recruiting. The concept sounds interesting, but I can't see it working out fairly.

That's why my suggestion is to reduce the bonus and clan exp if the war is not started by the main leader. This will promote more clan activity. At least others will not be idle as long as the remaining groups have enough participants to create another war.

Quite a fair idea. But what if there aren't that many number of members ?

Of course they will not be able to start. As per normal, it must be at least 10, 15, 20 and so on.

Actually, the bonus loot that the remaining team will gain will also depend on their ranking. So I guess, it will be still balance even without reducing it. It's just that they will be separated from the main force.

It will be more fun to see your clan members actively doing their best for war.

With this idea, the clan leader can also divide the clan into different war groups. So that whenever the war search start, all groups will finish at the same time.