Page 2 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 36

Thread: Dragons – Cancer of Clan Wars

  1. #11
    Millennial Club LegionOK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2014
    Posts
    1,007
    If you are TH7, you shouldn't be for very long. TH8 takes a little while and you'll be done with this. Basically, just upgrade your stuff and this is no longer going to be an issue for you.
    Most cups: 4826
    Leader: Oklahoma Rage, 7th United States Top 200 Clan to lvl 11
    1 billion+ gg; lvl 186; 404020 heroes; 100% cheeto walls

  2. #12
    Millennial Club
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Posts
    1,391

    Um your calculations are seriously off

    Quote Originally Posted by Nitecrawller View Post
    The strongest troop in the game should not be an instant 3 star at its level. But that does not mean it shouldnt be able to run over a small base. Otherwise what is the point of having high level troops if they cant make things easy for you. Even lvl6 BARCH can 3 star a th6/7....that doesn't mean BARCH is overpowered.

    Talking about drags at th7.....firstly

    Its costs 1.5m to unlock drags in 1 barracks....if a player makes an all drags army it wud take 5 hours which is a LOT OF TIME INVESTMENT

    It would cost 6m to unlock drags in 4 barracks.....if a player makes an all drag army it wud take atleast which 1.5 hrs....which considering for a th7 is STILL A LOT OF TIME INVESTMENT.

    To unlock lvl2 drags is 2m..which is a significant amount at th7

    LVL1 drag army without spells - 250k elixir
    Lvl2 drag army without spells - 300k elixir
    War loot for hitting a TH7 - 50k-60k ONLY
    War loot for hitting a TH8 - no profit in elixir again

    I agree it is difficult to defend against drags at th7 but If someone is ready to invest so much time and elixir for a team cause and sheer fun of playing the game and enjoying it then so be it.

    It is by no means an easy task to get your th7s to do all drag attacks....Even to a large extent th8s...So if a team is hammering you with their drags then they are more passionate about the game and deserve to win. The know how to attack with drags and deserve to win again. If you say they close their eyes and 3 star then your layouts and bases are terrible in defense and again the other team deserves to win.

    The only reason people want to complain about getting hammered by drags

    They dont know how to use them - I have seen tons of all drag armies only 1 star th7s and th8s

    They dont know how to defend against them

    They dont want to put the effort that the other team is putting and want supercell to do something about their laziness.

    If you only unlock one barracks then yeah it could take that long, but that's just stupid. Our th7s do not use mass dragons unless they have sooooo much elixer, which happens late in the game, and are seriously short on scouting time. But the th7 they hit are good for around 200 to 250 thousand each minimum. Most times it's closer to 300. So still not profitable, but war is not about profit or farming.

    as for not knowing how to use them .......it takes zero skill to zap and drop on a th7. Just a tiny bit more forethought on up to a mid level 8, but that's still marginal in my experience.

    We aren't big dragon users. We do use them, but in conjunction with our other troops. We rarely loose and we detest dragon spamming. So nope your assessment isn't one size fits all.

    Btw we are about to conclude yet another win against a dragon spamming clan. They don't have the attacks left to catch us.

  3. #13
    Forum Superstar
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Posts
    3,091
    Quote Originally Posted by SiitpsErt View Post
    Greetings,

    I am the leader of a very active war clan, consisting mainly from town hall 7s and 8s, all of which are experienced players. Lately we've discovered an unfortunate phenomena; all-dragon attacks. 80% of our losses are due to this troop composition. Three starring a nearly maxed town hall seven with level 2+ dragons requires no planning whatsoever.
    Furthermore, at town hall 7 it's practically impossible to design a viable anti-air base. The two air defenses available go only to level 5, providing the firepower to take out two or three dragons before they overrun the base completely.

    To counter this flaw, low-level air defense should be somehow buffed. Increasing the amount of seeking air mines at low levels would balance the problem to some extent.
    Fortunately TH7 does not take very long so it will only be a matter of a few weeks for your clan of mainly town hall 7s and 8s to be a clan of mainly town hall 8s and 9s at which point mass dragon attacks will be something you look forward to since they will perform so poorly against your base.

    The last attack against my TH9 base was mass dragons. I have 3 level 6 air defenses (which are the max level for TH8) and a level 2 air defense. The attack was a 71% 1 star attack. Even though I have completely neglected my air defenses at TH9 (having upgraded none of my level 6 air defenses from where they were at TH8 and only upgrading the new air defense to level 2) and my CC had no troops in it, the mass dragon attack was still only 1 star. This is normal when mass dragons are used against well developed TH8 bases and low TH9 bases. Mass dragons truly won't be a problem for your clan for long.

  4. #14
    Super Member Nitecrawller's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Posts
    956
    Quote Originally Posted by Mobad View Post
    If you only unlock one barracks then yeah it could take that long, but that's just stupid. Our th7s do not use mass dragons unless they have sooooo much elixer, which happens late in the game, and are seriously short on scouting time. But the th7 they hit are good for around 200 to 250 thousand each minimum. Most times it's closer to 300. So still not profitable, but war is not about profit or farming.

    as for not knowing how to use them .......it takes zero skill to zap and drop on a th7. Just a tiny bit more forethought on up to a mid level 8, but that's still marginal in my experience.

    We aren't big dragon users. We do use them, but in conjunction with our other troops. We rarely loose and we detest dragon spamming. So nope your assessment isn't one size fits all.

    Btw we are about to conclude yet another win against a dragon spamming clan. They don't have the attacks left to catch us.


    If what you are saying is true then the war loot might not be the same for every th7...maybe you dont have a lot of th8s and th9s in your clan(just guessing)...coz i could show you my war log and the top most th7 only gave 58.5k war loot.

    Your th7s dont use mass drags...no one is forcing anybody...like i said its difficult to get th7s to do drag atks

    Yes i agree war is not about farming or profit...thats what people complaining about drag atks generally want it to be

    I did not write as an advocate of all drag atks...merely realise the amount of time and resources that go into it.....yes it does take skill to attack with drags - (th8 and up with good layouts)...and also u cant close ur eyes and atk th7s

    You just won a war against a drag spamming clan proves that drag attacks require skill

    The OP was against drag attacks in war and was pointing out how powerful they are.

    But you just proved that they are not all that powerful and that they require skill to do them. Otherwise no one would ever win a war against drag spammers
    Last edited by Nitecrawller; March 2nd, 2015 at 12:13 AM.

  5. #15
    Pro Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    France
    Posts
    627
    I've never seen a TH7 not 3-starred by mass dragon, and 3x lightning. Never. The attacker can disconnect after dropping the dragons, it's that easy...
    However many people are reluctant to do that, because if the clan loose it's such a big loss...

    It's much more difficult against a TH8... I can often get 3 stars, but it's certainly not a guarantee, it can become 2 stars very quickly. And some clanmates often get just one...
    With a good design, I usually concede only one star against dragons and balloons.

    Against a TH9, I've seen some 2 stars, but most attack fails and give 1 star (or nothing).

  6. #16
    Forum Veteran Birdcraft's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Posts
    1,520

    I'm a new th7

    Quote Originally Posted by Nitecrawller View Post
    If what you are saying is true then the war loot might not be the same for every th7...maybe you dont have a lot of th8s and th9s in your clan(just guessing)...coz i could show you my war log and the top most th7 only gave 58.5k war loot.

    Your th7s dont use mass drags...no one is forcing anybody...like i said its difficult to get th7s to do drag atks

    Yes i agree war is not about farming or profit...thats what people complaining about drag atks generally want it to be

    I did not write as an advocate of all drag atks...merely realise the amount of time and resources that go into it.....yes it does take skill to attack with drags - (th8 and up with good layouts)...and also u cant close ur eyes and atk th7s

    You just won a war against a drag spamming clan proves that drag attacks require skill

    The OP was against drag attacks in war and was pointing out how powerful they are.

    But you just proved that they are not all that powerful and that they require skill to do them. Otherwise no one would ever win a war against drag spammers
    like I've only been here for 5 days. Just long enough to gem my lab and then upgrade my loons to 4 and get rage spells. I attacked another th7 in war. He had both teslas. I don't. His air defenses were both level 4. I have one at 4 and 1 at 2. He attacked me with all dragons. 100%. I used ballonion, but got the minions from a mate. I got 100%. My loot bonus off him was 250000 gold and elixer and 560 de. I have never gotten the low loot you are talking about even when I was a th4. I think you are seeing a loot penalty that pertains to a higher level attacking low, because unless those th7s are so poorly developed that they are more th3 than th7 there is no way your amount accurately reflects true loot bonuses for a th7 attacking another th7.

  7. #17
    Super Member Nitecrawller's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Posts
    956
    Quote Originally Posted by Birdcraft View Post
    like I've only been here for 5 days. Just long enough to gem my lab and then upgrade my loons to 4 and get rage spells. I attacked another th7 in war. He had both teslas. I don't. His air defenses were both level 4. I have one at 4 and 1 at 2. He attacked me with all dragons. 100%. I used ballonion, but got the minions from a mate. I got 100%. My loot bonus off him was 250000 gold and elixer and 560 de. I have never gotten the low loot you are talking about even when I was a th4. I think you are seeing a loot penalty that pertains to a higher level attacking low, because unless those th7s are so poorly developed that they are more th3 than th7 there is no way your amount accurately reflects true loot bonuses for a th7 attacking another th7.
    Well yes you are right on the war loot front....i didnt know war loot is different for different members..my bad

  8. #18
    Millennial Club
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Posts
    1,391

    Lol

    Quote Originally Posted by Nitecrawller View Post
    If what you are saying is true then the war loot might not be the same for every th7...maybe you dont have a lot of th8s and th9s in your clan(just guessing)...coz i could show you my war log and the top most th7 only gave 58.5k war loot.

    Your th7s dont use mass drags...no one is forcing anybody...like i said its difficult to get th7s to do drag atks

    Yes i agree war is not about farming or profit...thats what people complaining about drag atks generally want it to be

    I did not write as an advocate of all drag atks...merely realise the amount of time and resources that go into it.....yes it does take skill to attack with drags - (th8 and up with good layouts)...and also u cant close ur eyes and atk th7s

    You just won a war against a drag spamming clan proves that drag attacks require skill

    The OP was against drag attacks in war and was pointing out how powerful they are.

    But you just proved that they are not all that powerful and that they require skill to do them. Otherwise no one would ever win a war against drag spammers
    we won because their low levels couldn't fight their way out of a paper bag with holes and a map. All their 7s and 8s dragon spammed for easy 3 stars and reattacked for same, but they left th5 and 6s to their th6s that haven't learnt the art of lure. They wasted all their upper attacks throwing dragons everywhere and then lost because our little guys beat the snot out of them for three stars each.

    I beg to differ about the ease of dragon spamming. My oldest son and my youngest have both just dropped dragons anywhere on the map and 3 starred. These were not terrible or low leveled bases either. They are that over powered. Our decision to not mass dragon has zero to do with cost and more to do with figuring out how to actually take a base apart. Yes dragons can do the job.....easily, but it's more about succeeding WITH some skill and developing an eye for base weaknesses that will help later on. Since we win almost all our wars I would venture were are doing just fine with our strategy. Our clan has zero th9. We prefer it that way.

    i disagreed majorly with your comment concerning those that complained about dragon use. We don't like the spamming, but we do know how to use them. As stated your assessments were erroneous. I see another poster has corrected you on the loot bonus and others as to ease of dragon usage, so I'll just leave it there.

  9. #19
    Banned
    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Posts
    1,545
    Sure against TH7 up to mid TH8, dragons rule. However, this is a failed proposition against advanced TH8 and higher, resulting in mostly 2-stars, rarely 3-stars.

    Even against those Th7 to mid TH8, it is not a 3-star guarantee. Sure, for skilled attackers, it should be a no brainer. However, i have seen my fair share of failed dragons attacks on those 'easy' bases.

  10. #20
    Centennial Club
    Join Date
    Oct 2014
    Location
    Los Angeles
    Posts
    174
    I thought ninjas were supposed to have a fully functional brain.

    edit: the OPs premise is just overwhelmingly wrong. Even hogs at th7 are stronger than dragons. Oh no! Did I just give the game aids?
    Last edited by Drewdown; March 2nd, 2015 at 03:33 AM.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •