War participation enforcement

[Blowy]

Please for the love of all thats holy can we deny people taking part in clan wars the option to leave the clan.
This must have been brought up before but simply picking your team falls short of holding fair wars when people just leave, this always gives an unfair advantage to the opposing team.

[victort]

Please for the love of all thats holy can we deny people taking part in clan wars the option to leave the clan.
This must have been brought up before but simply picking your team falls short of holding fair wars when people just leave, this always gives an unfair advantage to the opposing team.

It must be a pain, and I can see its annoying - but forcing them to stay doesn't realy fix it, does it? How do you ensure they attack?

[Blowy]

You dont, simply they are left with the option to attack (as they might as well) or not bother....everyone wins.

[victort]

You dont, simply they are left with the option to attack (as they might as well) or not bother....everyone wins.

Not being argumentative - but how does everyone win? -- If someone wants out but is forced to stay, they are unlikely to go full on in a war they dont care about... If they dont attack nobody benefits niether the clan or the player....... (or if they just barch a star or attack low, it just annoys the other clan members - more disharmony -- however thats just my opinion ....

[rolph]

What will you do if that D-bag guy will spam your clan chat and be offensive? He would be enforced to stay anyway?

[Blowy]

What will you do if that D-bag guy will spam your clan chat and be offensive? He would be enforced to stay anyway?

Thats a valid point Rolph, however he/she would still be able to be dealt with via the existing kick system.

[Blowy]

Not being argumentative - but how does everyone win? -- If someone wants out but is forced to stay, they are unlikely to go full on in a war they dont care about... If they dont attack nobody benefits niether the clan or the player....... (or if they just barch a star or attack low, it just annoys the other clan members - more disharmony -- however thats just my opinion ....

Yep another good point but enforcement in wars is designed to combat your average hopper not punish a player. A player can always ask to be removed by an admin as a result.

Did you know that some players organise continuous war participation within friendly clans to unfairly boost clan wins and gain endless loot. We are not talking simply hoppers but an almost shadow game manipulation.

[victort]

Yep another good point but enforcement in wars is designed to combat your average hopper not punish a player. A player can always ask to be removed by an admin as a result.

Did you know that some players organise continuous war participation within friendly clans to unfairly boost clan wins and gain endless loot. We are not talking simply hoppers but an almost shadow game manipulation.

ah, I see now..... I will go fetch my tinfoil hat, before the illuminati get me......

[Blowy]

If your inferring im paranoid i may agree with you a little (im laughing typing this), but i clash alot and i have had people join and expressly ask the later. I work hard for my trophies and loot why should we ALL allow game manipulation to go on? Hoppers on the other hand are just an irritant that can be stamped out with some clever coding

[Northernrider]

Simple solution to anyone leaving clan during war would be to allow clan leader to put them on a revenge list so everyone in the clan could have a way to voice their unpleasure.