Handy tool for leaders to see who is a team player. (With a picture. Yay!)

[Flanoos]

great idea!
I love it. This give a reason to players to donate in clan wars. I think 30XP should be given to clan.

[LachNessMeownster]

great idea!
I love it. This give a reason to players to donate in clan wars. I think 30XP should be given to clan.

Appreciate the feedback. Thanks

[AxionXD]

Sorry for the real bad photo editing skills.

My eyes! They buuuurrrnn!

i do like the idea of this but it should just be part of the xp achievement screen. Like the first one, if 10 different people donate, you get 5xp if 20 different people donate you get 10xp. I think its a good idea but it shouldnt be extremely high. Sometimes you only want the top half of the clan to donate as they have higher troops.

[Drackos]

(Not needed to say with pictures btw)

I disagree. It's shouldn't be counted as clan exp. or any kind of exp. as far as showing how many times it's been dropped and who donated: Disagree. Most clans i've been in; never had to drop troops. 1-4 people fill clan castles. No need to show a total.

[LachNessMeownster]

(Not needed to say with pictures btw)

I disagree. It's shouldn't be counted as clan exp. or any kind of exp. as far as showing how many times it's been dropped and who donated: Disagree. Most clans i've been in; never had to drop troops. 1-4 people fill clan castles. No need to show a total.

Haha, the with pictures is something I have always done. Sort of my signature.
There have been times where I havent and a mod has litteraly changed the title to say (without pictures. Naw )

Anyhoo, on topic. Fair enough opinion, but I just dont feel it should have to be the same 4 people donating. Of course many circumstances can be different, eg: only 3=4 players with max troops.
But my clan is all maxed out players, with maxed out troops. Doesnt seem fair that people cant see who the donators are.

Thats also why I made it such a small xp reward, something to inspire people, but not enough to be a big deal.

[Gremlin4]

"Oh look another thread... Oh wait, WITH PICTURES? LACH HAS ANOTHER IDEA!"

^^ Pretty much me

I support this idea, though wouldn't people abuse the system? If people just keep donating to someone who is clearing his CC, then everyone could donate to the same person... Just a thought?

[meonhoc]

I don't care about reward when someone donates, it's for the war and the win is our reward .

I do think it's needed to know who is doing their part and who is messing with war castle so we can help stop it and make it better. Any clan who doesn't need this feature, congratulations, you are in a well organized clan, now please let some new clan struggling with recruiting member and keeping the clan organized have a way to improve theirs.

To avoid abuse mentioned by Gremlin, if troops are dismissed, then they could be deducted from the count .

Edit: when member A dismisses troops donated by member B, member B can donate again. It means somehow the troops are related to member B and the limit of 5 troops is in real time. Now let's have a number we all can see

[jita]

I like the idea but this could cause even more unnecessary clan drama. If a clan wants everyone to donate then they need to recruit team players or set up donation systems. Great idea though.

[sylveonzmushi]

Nice one laddie!We should have that!

OLAF IS THAT YOU?

Speaking of this topic. I like it.

[WarriorRudy]

Love this idea!