War Donations ~ |Discussion| (Without pictures. Naw!)

[LachNessMeownster]

I think this idea could go with clan perks, surely some clan levels should allow you to do this.

I like that idea, or perhaps the opposite way around.

Additional clan xp if every member donates. Only a very small amount of clan xp, but some incentive is better than none. And it would certainly encourage people to donate.

[AgingBlitzer]

What if youre the best player in the clan, is it fair that you donate max troops to everyone below you, and then get crumby troops in return? From my point of view, no.

so get the clan perks that upgrades donated troops
the solution is already out there

[LachNessMeownster]

so get the clan perks that upgrades donated troops
the solution is already out there

Fair enough.
Unless youre a non war clan.

[Ideaman]

maybe it should be that you can only donate like 3 troops instead of 5, 4 instead of 6, and 5 instead of 8.

[Tsampsel25]

Simply because it's not at all the idea behind it. The purpose of a clan is for members to help each other. If you can donate to yourself, then it will quickly becomes a "help yourself, we don't fill CC for others" and would defeat the purpose of a clan.

Couldnt have said it better myself! There is a reason it is called clan wars and not my war. Its about being a team.