Is it true that a top5 th5 will give same exp as top5 th10?

[Pete82]

No, think about it: is it easier or harder to star a th5 or a th10? So therefor the experience should be scaled, right? At the moment it is nearly impossible not to star a non-Max th, whereas it is possible to not star a max th. Therefore, shouldn't there be different amounts of experience available? Ensuring that there is the same experience to difficulty ratio?

You could never ensure the same experience to difficulty ratio, because of the skill multiplier. I'm kidding of course, but the point is one simple system is preferable for all players. You will not see level 10 clans full of TH5s. For soooo many reasons it just is not a concern.

Could a group of TH7s and TH8s stick together and wind up with a high level clan? Sure, why not? I think we will see the last few levels are going to take tons of time, and in that time they probably won't be TH7s or TH8s anymore....

I guess I just don't see the issue.

[Gama321]

I think that higher ths should be getting more exp. That's how I thought it was in the beginning and it seemed perfectly natural to me.
But in the end of the day it doesn't make much difference. Any good th10 should be able to 2 star another th10, and the star bonus is 60% so you will achieve it. That being said 2 starring a th10 is way harder than 2 starring a th5, so I think that % could do with a rise on the lower levels. It should be a goal that is achieved by any good clan all the time. Mediocre clans shouldn't be getting that bonus all the time, and lower ths just have it so easy.

[AABCDS]

You haven't thought about this at all have you?

How do you get a TH5 in the top five in clan wars? By having a bunch of TH5s and lower on both sides. The difficulty of one-starring a TH5 by a TH5 or lower is approximately the same as a TH10 one-starring another TH10.

P.S. Your poll options make no sense whatsoever given the thread title question.

[Gama321]

You haven't thought about this at all have you?

How do you get a TH5 in the top five in clan wars? By having a bunch of TH5s and lower on both sides. The difficulty of one-starring a TH5 by a TH5 or lower is approximately the same as a TH10 one-starring another TH10.

P.S. Your poll options make no sense whatsoever given the thread title question.

Do you actually believe that?

But I guess you are right, if you tried to get one star you would end up with 100% most of the time

[Pranav]

It will be hard for a TH5 to 3-star a fellow a TH5, if they have a good base. You can say this for any town hall equivalents really, because the base and troops are like equally matched. The level of difficulty is equal, so so should the XP. The only exception I would say is TH7, because of mass drags.

[Pete82]

It will be hard for a TH5 to 3-star a fellow a TH5, if they have a good base. You can say this for any town hall equivalents really, because the base and troops are like equally matched. The level of difficulty is equal, so so should the XP. The only exception I would say is TH7, because of mass drags.

Why are we talking about 3 starring? One star for the bonus, 60% of stars for the other bonus....right? Anyway, in general I would say 3 stars are tougher at each higher TH level.

[Pranav]

Why are we talking about 3 starring? One star for the bonus, 60% of stars for the other bonus....right? Anyway, in general I would say 3 stars are tougher at each higher TH level.

I guess you have a point... but it really shouldn't be hard to at least 1 or 2 star an equivalent TH just as long as you have right army for right base.

[Pete82]

I guess you have a point... but it really shouldn't be hard to at least 1 or 2 star an equivalent TH just as long as you have right army for right base.

Yes. I mean it is exceptionally easy to 3 star any base TH7 and lower. I think that was the OPs point, newer players are getting equal experience for easier work. They also get easier/better loot....

[elpresidente47]

And so what if TH5's gets it a bit easier.. you should be glad they do, because then they grow faster and soon you'll have more bases in your search queue. Loot problem fixed.

[mrtogue]

1 extremely high level base ( one with max troops ) who excludes himself from every war

and 45 low level bases that he feeds

the low level bases with the help of max troops would take out every base easily.

the only draw back is dealing with the limited clan castle space