Is it true that a top5 th5 will give same exp as top5 th10?

[gorzo93]

In war, apparently you get the same amount of clan experience for defeating a th5 as defeating a th10?

That seems a bit too ridiculous...I guess with this they are more so aiming the update at bridging the gap between new players and experienced players.

I thought it was just the additional levels perk that was aimed at this, but I just realised that this is too?

Do you guys think that it is fair that a new player will get the same amount of experience as an old player and a will get it a lot easier?

[tuesfutu]

Yes, it is true.

[gorzo93]

Yes, it is true.

You new players get everything easier! wish I hadn't started CoC until now!

[lolnopound]

Worst poll options ever?

[Radiating]

I don't mind. I've seen low level TH5 try to raid and other low levels, it can be painful to watch, let's just leave it at that. Some understand certain strategies, others do not. I think it's fair and fine, others may disagree obv.

[Pete82]

Worst poll options ever?

The OP is famous for it. No, I don't care nor do I think it remotely matters. These clan perks are not some amazing advantage. Sure, they will be nice to have. It will take awhile to get them, longer than anyone serious stays at TH5.

[erethizon]

They are not getting it any easier. The only way a TH5 base would be worth 5 experience is if there are less than 4 bases above TH5 in the entire clan. It's a clan of lowbies. Naturally they are going to face other low bases and they should be allowed to level up their clan just the same.

If you really think it is such an advantage feel free to start a new clan where you are the only base above a TH5 and tell me how much fun it is to have terrible donations all the time and to only play with people that know nothing about the game. Your two attacks may be easier, but watching them mess up on easy bases will be quite painful for you. I'll take a clan full of TH9's and TH10's over a clan full of TH5's any day.

[erethizon]

Worst poll options ever?

Definitely. The third option in the poll is supposed to be the one that agrees with his point of view, but what it actually says is that the game should work exactly how it does. Currently new players and loyal players are treated the same. They both can get 5 exp for the top 5 bases every war and 4 exp for the next 10. That is treating everyone exactly the same.

[gorzo93]

Worst poll options ever?

Please read the stickies before posting.

The OP is famous for it. No, I don't care nor do I think it remotely matters. These clan perks are not some amazing advantage. Sure, they will be nice to have. It will take awhile to get them, longer than anyone serious stays at TH5.

Please read the stickies before posting. So you don't agree that they are designed to bridge the gap between new and loyal players?

They are not getting it any easier. The only way a TH5 base would be worth 5 experience is if there are less than 4 bases above TH5 in the entire clan. It's a clan of lowbies. Naturally they are going to face other low bases and they should be allowed to level up their clan just the same.

If you really think it is such an advantage feel free to start a new clan where you are the only base above a TH5 and tell me how much fun it is to have terrible donations all the time and to only play with people that know nothing about the game. Your two attacks may be easier, but watching them mess up on easy bases will be quite painful for you. I'll take a clan full of TH9's and TH10's over a clan full of TH5's any day.

Maybe I was just lucky enough to be in a decent clan when I was a new player. We all started around the same time and we were all decent. It was very easy to three star any bases when nexting.

And Im not sure if you are trolling me when you say that it isn't easier to three star a th5 as a th5 than to three star a th10 as a th10. With very little knowledge or experience in coc a th8 and below will three star the same level. Th9 gets s bit harder but still very easy, especially with lavaloo now.

I'm not saying that I want to make a clan of only myself a max town hall player and fill the clan with th5s, that is a silly idea. But do you think that th5 vs th5 is that hard?

[gorzo93]

Definitely. The third option in the poll is supposed to be the one that agrees with his point of view, but what it actually says is that the game should work exactly how it does. Currently new players and loyal players are treated the same. They both can get 5 exp for the top 5 bases every war and 4 exp for the next 10. That is treating everyone exactly the same.

No, think about it: is it easier or harder to star a th5 or a th10? So therefor the experience should be scaled, right? At the moment it is nearly impossible not to star a non-Max th, whereas it is possible to not star a max th. Therefore, shouldn't there be different amounts of experience available? Ensuring that there is the same experience to difficulty ratio?