There should be a modest bonus for 3 starring all bases. Like 5 or 10 % of total won.
Also mandatory war once a week or you loose clan points. Also needs to be a maintain cost or risk of loss of xp in war
There should be a modest bonus for 3 starring all bases. Like 5 or 10 % of total won.
Also mandatory war once a week or you loose clan points. Also needs to be a maintain cost or risk of loss of xp in war
..............
Should your TH downgrade if you don't raid anyone for a week? I'm not sure if you're trolling or if you're serious, but why on earth would you suggest losing XP? The risk of not warring is that you stop leveling up your clan. Period. If you make it to level 10, you can sit back and enjoy the benefits. You earned them.Originally Posted by TexanDiablo
Regarding a bonus for 3 starring all bases, I think the bonus for that is bragging rights.
But I do think that the thresholds of 40% and 60% of max possible stars are really, really low. It's fine for super casual clans, like the one I'm in, but it's basically free stars for any serious clan.
In my clan, 10v10, I have three accounts. I regularly get 18 stars and hence would qualify for the 40% and 60% bonuses on my own. I used to win wars by myself before my clan started to pull it together. Now we have 7 active players, got our first 30 star victory last week. But generally we score between 18 and 23 stars, pretty typical for a casual clan with at least a couple active strong players.
So I think a max star bonus isn't necessary, but the 40% and 60% thresholds should have been higher. Basically, the max possible stars is a multiple of 15, and the bonuses are awarded at the respective multiple of 6 or 9. Maybe those should have been 8 and 12? For example, in 10v10, award a bonus for 16 stars (just past halfway), and the second bonus for 24 stars (3 starring the bottom 8, or 2-starring the top 6 and 3-starring the bottom 4, etc.) Getting 24 out of 30, or 120 out of 150, is already a pretty good accomplishment. Sure, the "serious" clans will say that's a cakewalk and that you didn't really try, but not every clan is "serious". I doubt more than 5% of clans are "serious" by that standard, and I'm only including clans that even bother to go to war.
Something tells me, however, that Supercell simply looked at a large sample of clan wars and picked targets they deemed reasonable, based on the CoC population at large. Active/serious war clans will far exceed these "typical" figures.
Posting Permissions
