Clan Levels

[wolpak]

I don't like the idea that everyone is just aiming to get 10 clan levels and then what? Just sit there as a "maxed" clan. Eventually, all clans will become level 10, unless there is something I am missing.

You should need to maintain your level. This means there should be ways to lose clan experience. Each base destroyed should be -5 points. Make better bases! And your level should decrease over time (you should have to maintain warring to keep the high level). Maybe -10 points a day.

[edomingox]

I like the idea of Clan Trophies. Just like our villages but for Clans. but he has a point. everyone can eventually get there, it's just going to be a difficult road at first.

So, as a solution, here's what you do.

At the end of the clan war there is a score. Say 23 to 27 stars. So clan 1 scored 23 and clan 2 scored 27. That means clan 2 gains 4 trophies (27 - 23 = 4 taken from the losing clan). From there, certain perks can be maintained as long as they stay in a certain range, like the "league".

[WarrenJames]

I don't like the idea that everyone is just aiming to get 10 clan levels and then what? Just sit there as a "maxed" clan. Eventually, all clans will become level 10, unless there is something I am missing.

You should need to maintain your level. This means there should be ways to lose clan experience. Each base destroyed should be -5 points. Make better bases! And your level should decrease over time (you should have to maintain warring to keep the high level). Maybe -10 points a day.

Yes, having worked with the system for weeks now, this idea...

Wait.. How the heck would you know how the Clan Level system even plays? It hasn't been several days yet! You have no way of figuring out how long it takes to get to level 10, nor know if Supercell will or will not add more later.

Give it several weeks, then start complaining about stuff like this.

[TexanDiablo]

I agree there needs to be a maintain system. Maybe once a week you have to war and each war has a risk of xp if you loss.

[WarrenJames]

What?! You guys haven't even had the system for two days and you want it to eat away at your XP progress?! Do you know how bad this idea sounds to the average person?

[TheOneTheyCallSmasher]

Yes, having worked with the system for weeks now, this idea...

Wait.. How the heck would you know how the Clan Level system even plays? It hasn't been several days yet! You have no way of figuring out how long it takes to get to level 10, nor know if Supercell will or will not add more later.

Give it several weeks, then start complaining about stuff like this.

What?! You guys haven't even had the system for two days and you want it to eat away at your XP progress?! Do you know how bad this idea sounds to the average person?

Warren... The question was answered in your first post. Why post again to say the same thing?

I call spam


Jk jk sorry please forgive me pleeeease I'm sorry warren.

[WarrenJames]

Warren... The question was answered in your first post. Why post again to say the same thing?

I call spam


Jk jk sorry please forgive me pleeeease I'm sorry warren.

*facepalms and groans*
I'm not 'you are reported to mods' trigger happy. Just that one thread was really really bad, and half of the reporting I forgot to do afterwards. x.x; Yes I report spam, ad bots, and go clearly ruled-out threads on the spot, but people...

---

Anyway... If you guys really really want an option on decay or whatever, set it to where if a member leaves, an assigned amount of XP goes with them (or whatever fair amount) The clan is only as experienced as the people in it, and so people going (and coming?) would affect the XP.

Likely too realistic and prone to abuse, but that's a top-of-my-head thing that makes more sense than just X amount of XP goes missing because of 'reasons'.

[cariacou]

I don't like the idea that everyone is just aiming to get 10 clan levels and then what? Just sit there as a "maxed" clan. Eventually, all clans will become level 10, unless there is something I am missing.

You should need to maintain your level. This means there should be ways to lose clan experience. Each base destroyed should be -5 points. Make better bases! And your level should decrease over time (you should have to maintain warring to keep the high level). Maybe -10 points a day.

Dumbest idea ever.
Send me an email when you get to clan lvl10. I'll start a new clash account and see if I can fully max it (with walls & heroes) before you get there.

[AlvinSoehendryWijaya]

Sc dont like negative punishment
if this implement they should make people lv to be demoted or even building th and etc
just say they earn it

its call clan lv not clan thropy if its throphy then its need league
so there gonna be clan leader board and etc
there will be people in champs clan that have more benefit like higher league give bonus but still lv 10 clan is useless for maxxed clan with max troops
donated troops + 2 lv dont know what use for max player

[chrispeterson]

I agree there needs to be a maintain system. Maybe once a week you have to war and each war has a risk of xp if you loss.

The update literally just came out yesterday why does this need this feature already?