You know, with the two above ^^^ thread posts above, I'm getting a strangely nostalgic sense of deja vu...
Illustris the Fan of Tim's Soccer Legs
I have to say, it is actually a lot of fun, because it is different. If your higher trophy count, I can see it really effecting you, but at lower levels, you basically just offset your regular army knowing you are going to have giants or something else big in your cc.
We are dumping every raid anyways, so it isn't like the giants are staying for defence often enough to really matter, and more times then not, they are offset by the extra giants you donated yourself, so your still raiding with the same balance.
All in all, its only a week, and judging by the activity in clan chat, it has definitely worked in getting people more active and joking around. It isn't always about the most efficient numbers every time, and sometimes about growing a clan family closer together.
I have probably raided more times in the last day or so then I usually do in most of the week.
Just the opinion of a lowly TH7
(Insert Super special stats that nobody but me cares about nor wants to see here)
(Insert stalker info like clan and elder status which nobody needs to know)