Fail
Very Bad IdeaOriginally Posted by Skenderbeu
Hello Everybody,
On TH10 bases the gap between getting 2 stars (not too tough) and 3 stars (very difficult, almost impossible) is too wide.
The wars are getting a little bit boring in clans that all players have a townhall lvl10.
Every war it`s the same all attacks look similar trying to get 2 Stars with gowiwi, gowipe and lavaloon. To increase the dynamics i propose a 4 star clan war system.
This is how it works:
- 1 STAR- (Destroying an opponents Town Hall) /or/ (50% of enemy`s buildings)
- 2 STAR- (Destroying an opponents Town Hall)+(50% of enemy`s buildings) /or/ (75% of enemy`s buildings)
- 3 STAR- (Destroying an opponents Town Hall)+(75% of enemy`s buildings)
- 4 STAR- 100% Annihilation awards full 4 star.
For those who think it's complicated (same calculation, different view):
- 1 Star: 50% - 74% damage (except TH of course) / (+1 star bonus if TH destroyed)
- 2 Star: 75% - 99% damage (except TH of course) / (+1 star bonus if TH destroyed)
- 3 Star: 75% - 99% damage ( + TH of course)
- 4 Star: 100%
NOTE: The change will be minimal, you get another 1 star when you destroy 75% of enemy`s buildings... easy to implement I guess... since the game already keeps track (and notifies) of 75% destruction in wars'
All comments are welcome, especially constructive criticism!
If you disagree with this idea for any reasons, please explain to me why, thanks!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Check also Adelima19 comments where you can find your answers:
It has nothing to do with 1 99% 1 stars or all that other stuff.. that stuff happens yes it will be a 99% 2 star now but we are not talking about that. ya it will still suck you cant change that in the game. the WHOLE point is the jump from 50% with getting the TH to getting a three star 100% is way to big... let me break it down
Right now -
1 Star = 50%. I would say easy to get.
1 Star = TH. I would say a little harder to get depending on base layout.
2 Stars = 50% + TH. I would say Medium + hard depending on base layout, and skill. if you can get 50% of the base you should be able to get the TH fairly easy. they almost go hand and hand.
3 Stars = 100% destroyed... This can be nearly impossible to get.
Now I know your saying 3 Star is not impossible, but I don't mean lvl 8 TH's and below. I"m talking higher lvl Lvl 9, and 10 TH's which is the only reason this I coming up. with lower levels the 4 stars does nothing, as 3 staring a base is easy enough. So you can see above that the jump from 2 to 3 stars is HUGE. from ah not to hard to get, all the way to ya I have a 2% of getting 3 stars. but looking at a 4 star system
4 Stars-
1 Star = 50%. I would say easy to get.
1 Star = TH. I would say a little harder to get depending on base layout.
2 Stars = 50% + TH. I would say Medium + hard depending on base layout, and skill. if you can get 50% of the base you should be able to get the TH fairly easy. they almost go hand and hand.
2 Stars = 75% would be hard to get this without getting the TH but it can happen its like the 99% 1 Stars. if this happens then the attack just didn't go right.
3 Stars = 75% + TH, this would be hard to do, as its easy to get 50% + TH but to get over the 75% destruction can be a challenge.
4 Stars = 100% destroyed... This can be nearly impossible to get.
With this you get a good range through out and more options. with you saying to keep the 3 Star system you are saying a clan getting 50% 2 stars is just as good as the clan getting 99% 2 stars.... basically these clan wars at higher lvls are now becoming 2 star systems as mostly everyone can 2 star but not 3 star bases
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I follow what your saying if you are not meant to 3 Star a lvl 10 TH then these wars of lvl 10 TH are always going to end a Tie because everyone will get 2 Stars, and you missing the point you are jumping from Easy to get 2 Stars to impossible... people will have to "practice to get 3 Stars now, and then practice to get 4 Stars. right now people are saying 2 stars is good enough because 3 stars Is impossible!! and it will still be hard to get 75% and TH. you have to though perfection out the window it don't exist. the main problem I have with the 3 Star system is you see these wars with one clan getting 50-55% 2 stars and the other clan is getting 80% 2 stars... but clearly one clan is better then the other but it is not being shown.
