Good Idea!
I think it's a good idea. I can see where you are comming from, and many Clan wars have ended in disaster because of a perculiar star system and I think this woul dbe a much more honnest way of doing it. Maybe only for Wars but I don't know. Good job though!
Originally Posted by Scuba061
if you want a 5 star system with 25% victory i dont think thats a good idea.i still find 5 stars to be a good option!
my opinion , i respect yours too!
Last edited by Skenderbeu; March 16th, 2015 at 04:15 PM.
The problem with a 4 or 5 star system is that it lowers the value of getting to the TH. Before, you could 98% and only 1 star. Here, you could get 2 or even 3 stars, which significantly lowers the value the TH gives.
I am not saying I don't like it, I am saying it isn't just an extra star thing. It changes the dynamics quite a lot.
I think they may be heading that way anyhow. They are first working to make 3 stars very hard and that makes sense as a first step. 3 stars used to be too common and if everyone was getting 3 then everyone would just be getting 4 or 5 so what would be the point?
In order to have room for increasing the number of stars they have to first increase the amount of separation between 1, 2, and 3 star attacks and that has certainly been happening. (especially between 2 and 3)
If everything angers you then you will spend your entire life being angry.
If everything pains you then you will spend your entire life in pain.
i have explained very well all the points. may i ask what th are you and what th lvls is your clan mainly composed. My clan attack with lava-loons and all players are very good (most of attacks +75% or 100%) at war but with some good th10 bases we have the issue that is impossible to get 3stars especially when we fight with a stronger clan. However the difference in strength is not shown in the number of stars because we get 2stars and the other clan gets 2stars too. if we had a 4 star system the war results would be different and for all clans the attacks of a barely 50% +th that is really very simple ( i can get it with non specialized troops ) would not be good but normal.
Last edited by Skenderbeu; March 16th, 2015 at 04:56 PM.
I dislike the idea, the game dynamics are fine as they are, no need to change them in my opinion
TomJones, Member of Cruciatus; Epic lvl 4 War Clan-
CC:Lvl130 TH11, Sweet Victory 4024, Combined lvl45 Heroes, WH 700
CR:Lvl8, Highest 2709,Church of Will, 3CW 177, Donations 600
BB:Ll 52 HQ20, The Plague,
Signature Art: ThumperOG
thats the point! It should be a difference from an attack of 90% + the with an attack of 50% +th...
We can keep conditions of whether win or loss...
for example 60% gives you two stars! hence that is considered as a win but 35% gives only one star but considered a fail. for a victory two conditions must be satisfied...
1) atleast two stars
2)minimum 50% damage(this will ensure that town hall snipe wont be considered a win)
and by the way let the second star be at 60% and the third at 85%, the fourth can be th town hall and the fifth at 100%, this will be good!
Last edited by MehulJ; March 17th, 2015 at 06:44 AM.
How about keep the 3 star system, except for wars have one star awarded for TH and the other two star awarded as partial stars, from .02 to 2.00, ie. 25% = .50 stars. 77% = 1.54 stars. 99% = 1.98 stars.
easy to said boy..u just a th8 only..i just go to your stupid clan..i see your id..u know what? same on what i assume..u are just low th8...please read people thread carefully..dont just read title only..u just let everybody know how stupid u are...please keep away your stupid brain and dont spam there..here..over there..
for your information..th8 easy to get 3* when u in war..almost every attack..
but in th10..almost impossible to 3*,,for max th10..do u understand that fact?
u must fell u always do perfect attack when u get 3* in th8..hahaha..aiyoooo nak gelak aku
Posting Permissions
