Clan Wars Troop Donation Interface

[jdurant2]

Please make an effort to allow the users to track who is donating during clan wars. The friend in need stat doesn't even increment when you donate in war, so there is absolutely no way of knowing exactly who is donating in wars. The clan interface shows troops donated and troops received, so incorporating a troops donated into the clan war interface should not be a problem as the code should be very similar. Since the recent update, the leader and co-leaders are allowed to opt players in and out of war. You should also allow them to remove troops from anyone's clan castle. This will allow the requests to be fulfilled correctly. Hell, even making a fully interactive troop donation system would be a great improvement to the current system. Each player in war should fill out exactly what troops they want in their clan castle. Then only allow those troops to be donated to the clan castle, rejecting those troops that were not requested by the player. This will ensure that the request is satisfied completely. This problem needs to be addressed as we do not know who has donated against the requests of others. Please look into this supercell. Also, please vote on the poll I have created and leave a comment about the current donation system below. Maybe if we get enough votes and raise enough awareness they will be more inclined to fix the issue.

[willmayne]

this is a good ides and i think how much war donations should be put wright next to your normal donations on the clan interface

[CruzWARRR]

this is a good ides and i think how much war donations should be put wright next to your normal donations on the clan interface

And think of all the lvl 4 GIANTS you will get in your warbase if u mistakenly allow a hopper in!? I would rather have the ability to make it so members can't donate to war cc's. Now that would be fun!

[DeepFriedBanana]

I think there would be no problem with this

[Tpjones]

yeah do it

[edomingox]

Please make an effort to allow the users to track who is donating during clan wars. The friend in need stat doesn't even increment when you donate in war, so there is absolutely no way of knowing exactly who is donating in wars. The clan interface shows troops donated and troops received, so incorporating a troops donated into the clan war interface should not be a problem as the code should be very similar. Since the recent update, the leader and co-leaders are allowed to opt players in and out of war. You should also allow them to remove troops from anyone's clan castle. This will allow the requests to be fulfilled correctly. Hell, even making a fully interactive troop donation system would be a great improvement to the current system. Each player in war should fill out exactly what troops they want in their clan castle. Then only allow those troops to be donated to the clan castle, rejecting those troops that were not requested by the player. This will ensure that the request is satisfied completely. This problem needs to be addressed as we do not know who has donated against the requests of others. Please look into this supercell. Also, please vote on the poll I have created. Maybe if we get enough votes, they will be more inclined to fix the issue.

Another Idea
Should allow Clans to acquire gold or some other currency through clan wars to then be used to enter into clan tournaments. The prize for winning the tournaments might be more gold for the clan or individual elixir and gold for its members. Would be a great dynamic to the game

It looks like you have several ideas within your first paragraph. You should parse it out. But here's my take:
1. Who donates: I think it's been suggested before. I forgot why but many people (the experienced players) are not agreeing with this.
2. allowing leaders to remove troops: This is mentioned too. I don't like it because it gives too much control to the leaders.
3. interactive troop donation: Again, mentioned a lot. Again, it may not be done because the player can simply remove the troop themselves and send out another request. The clan members must communicate between each other clearly.

part of the reason for #3 is probably because of the clan hoppers donating giants all the time. Which is a strategy people use to get the troop donation achievement.

Your clan tournament idea, I like it. I think it's been suggested many times as well. The only issue I see is people with multiple accounts in clans sabotaging or spying in the tournament placed within the same tournament in multiple clans.

[OamnraML]

It looks like you have several ideas within your first paragraph. You should parse it out. But here's my take:
1. Who donates: I think it's been suggested before. I forgot why but many people (the experienced players) are not agreeing with this.
2. allowing leaders to remove troops: This is mentioned too. I don't like it because it gives too much control to the leaders.
3. interactive troop donation: Again, mentioned a lot. Again, it may not be done because the player can simply remove the troop themselves and send out another request. The clan members must communicate between each other clearly.

part of the reason for #3 is probably because of the clan hoppers donating giants all the time. Which is a strategy people use to get the troop donation achievement.

Your clan tournament idea, I like it. I think it's been suggested many times as well. The only issue I see is people with multiple accounts in clans sabotaging or spying in the tournament placed within the same tournament in multiple clans.

I think #3 ahould be implemented though. Not everyone had the 24hour freetime to play, as not everybody had the luxury to stay at home for 24/7. We need to work though.

There is 1 time where I was in an international clan with 'everyone can join' clan, due to working and in a different time zone, all my cc were filled with wb. 10 wb. Giants would be better. While it made me mad, but it sure is a good laugh when I think about it now. LOL.

But I think its not that necessary either.

[PwnTime]

There should definitely be a separate record set aside for when people donate to defensive war clan castles. Wars are becoming a huge part of this game and being one of the leaders to a b2b war clan, I need to be able to keep track of who donates during war prep and who isn't. Not only for the sake of promotions, but just generally being able to keep track of who is contributing to clan growth and who isn't is very important and shouldn't be overlooked.

[OamnraML]

There should definitely be a separate record set aside for when people donate to defensive war clan castles. Wars are becoming a huge part of this game and being one of the leaders to a b2b war clan, I need to be able to keep track of who donates during war prep and who isn't. Not only for the sake of promotions, but just generally being able to keep track of who is contributing to clan growth and who isn't is very important and shouldn't be overlooked.

Agreed. Sometimes it hard to keep track of who is donating. Most of the time, hoppers would put inside wallbreakers, or gobs and then don't attack for the rest of the war. As a leader in my clan, I had to compare the troops level to find out the troller is, and kick him out even in the middle of the war.

[immortalzrizing]

excellent ideas and allowing leads n co leads to remove troops would be a huge benefit to misplaced donations.