Why the players go Off the clan after WAR Started? Put an End to it

[buntingan]

This is why your have been so off in your approach. You think I am perceiving or deciding something. I am simply telling you. Yes, is a thread killer. SC meant it to be exactly that. What I am adding is the most useful input that could possibly be getting put here.

You think you have something useful to add but what you are really doing is just repeating the same old stuff SC has already heard many times, considered it, passed on it, and has now taken to saying they don't want to hear it any more. Given that being the situation the thread should be killed. Its just taking up bandwidth from the guys that do have something new and useful to suggest. Its why SC created the sticky's and posted that list.

The forum does get cluttered with a lot of whining from kids that can't handle their own challenges and want someone else to do it for them. No matter how you want to phrase it, that is what we have here so in those cases thread killing is a good thing.

Yep its is pretty much taking the bandwith specially we are already out of topic as its is already about your response on the idea. Ideas can always be recycled and grinded for its worth. If its ruled out before so be it dont to over emphasis let thoughts and views roll and let it die on its own or deleted by SC. Sorry im no whining kid and maybe older than you as you lack the creativitity and patience to expand on ideas.

Out of topic totally sorry.

[rwelshjr]

Yep its is pretty much taking the bandwith specially we are already out of topic as its is already about your response on the idea. Ideas can always be recycled and grinded for its worth. If its ruled out before so be it dont to over emphasis let thoughts and views roll and let it die on its own or deleted by SC. Sorry im no whining kid and maybe older than you as you lack the creativitity and patience to expand on ideas.

Out of topic totally sorry.

Actually, I was not the one that said it was ruled out. I was the one that suggested you were being ridiculous for getting mad at the guys that were.

The topic was on the OPs idea and it was in fact being discussed despite being ruled out (it was being explained what OP was not thinking of when he came up with it so that he could understand why SC decided what they did) when a couple guys (including you) weighed in griping about guys saying that ruled out stuff was ruled out. You simply didn't understand that it was the right thing for those guys to say. But since sometimes facing reality is too hard for some guys so you got mad instead. (and yes, you are) So stay mad I guess. Retort, whatever. Or try to explain why iceageg's explanation does not hold water. I think that is pretty accurate how it would work if they actually did try putting this in.

[karthimx]

Better Leader has an option to select who want to be in WAR. May be this will reduce hoppers.

[buntingan]

Actually, I was not the one that said it was ruled out. I was the one that suggested you were being ridiculous for getting mad at the guys that were.

The topic was on the OPs idea and it was in fact being discussed despite being ruled out (it was being explained what OP was not thinking of when he came up with it so that he could understand why SC decided what they did) when a couple guys (including you) weighed in griping about guys saying that ruled out stuff was ruled out. You simply didn't understand that it was the right thing for those guys to say. But since sometimes facing reality is too hard for some guys so you got mad instead. (and yes, you are) So stay mad I guess. Retort, whatever. Or try to explain why iceageg's explanation does not hold water. I think that is pretty accurate how it would work if they actually did try putting this in.

ok stick to your mad idea and the magic wand keep it. negative stat of iceageg was retorted so read the thread. if you cannot contribute on how this idea will be enhanced to passed with sc criteria, better stick to your wand business.

[KAIRIURDANETACHAMPS]

War is the core of the game.
Heart of clan description.
Most lovable is Clan Wars.
Put an end to Clan Hoppers/War Hoppers.

Please add a rule

"Players cannot able to leave the Clan, Once War started" and "Disable the leave option once the member is in war participant" . Only Leader do kick players after WAR STARTS.
Or
Ask them to use 30 Gems to leave the clan once the WAR Starts. Then some players will not do so. Keep on clashing, I love the Game. Updates rocks, always most welcome. Waiting for SneakPeek <3

OR
How many WAR STARS in one LEAGUE.
Adding New: It will be good if we can know "how many attacks done" in total wars the player played.
Adding a WAR STARS (Total no. of stars/Total no. of attacks) like Attacks Won, Defense Won, Troops Received and Troops Donated.

Thanks
Peenumx

i dont think sc wud approve of it, anyway leaving in a clan war when it just started sometimes can also be a strategy, and for clan who use spies so i dont think this would be updated

[rwelshjr]

ok stick to your mad idea and the magic wand keep it. negative stat of iceageg was retorted so read the thread. if you cannot contribute on how this idea will be enhanced to passed with sc criteria, better stick to your wand business.

Actually I spoke to the wand earlier and gave why that was a valid statement. Your desperation had you going back several posts looking for a phrase you could retort on. (and if that was the best you could could do then you are hard up indeed) Rather than speak to the good information posted here as to why this entire suggestion is foolish and short sighted you instead are doing that. I take it that since you have several times here passed on that 'debate and discussion' you so much claimed you were standing up for that you actually got nothing for that. Its often a sign of guys that got nothing to come back with is choosing to instead complain that the information got given as we can see in you continuing that path. Of course the information given kills the point you wanted to make. Its because the point you wanted to make was never valid. Get over it kid.

So the bottom line outcome of all this noise is that the OP's suggestion (original topic) was a short sighted bad idea. Its been pretty proven in the points several have made here. No one has been able to produce anything that can support it.

[Medici]

I agree with the idea but disagree that the war is core of the game. Because it's not.

[Drackos]

You need to remember who you are complaining about here. Either the player leaving is leaving because you have a poor clan and/or poor leadership, or they are leaving because they have questionable moral integrity. For the sake of argument lets assume you are a wise and effective leader, so this must be one of those d-bags that hangs you out to dry. If you get your way and players are forced to stay or penalized for leaving . . . <fade to foreshadowed scene>

1) D-bag joins
2) You start war
3) D-bag wants to leave but can't (SUCCESS!!! He is stuck with you now!!!)
4) D-bag is a d-bag and wants out, so he decides to get kicked out
5) So he fills war castles with goblins and wallbreakers
6) And fills donations with goblins and wall breakers
7) And turns your clan chat into something that makes global look like bible study
8) And defames your clan on global
9) Then wastes both attacks in the war anyway
9a) Set their base up so it is super easy to 3*
10) And continues to fill war requests with ♥♥♥♥ troops
11) Maybe even comes to the forums to badmouth you and your clan
12) You kick them out
or
12) Your other clan members leave because you won't kick out the D-bag

Remember, this is already a person who doesn't care if they hurt your clan. Long story short, you are requesting a way to force people who don't want to be in your clan, who you don't even want in your clan, to be stuck in your clan. NOTHING good can come of this. Bad idea every time it is suggested.

this guy sums it up pretty well. I can just set a base to a 3 star so that way I get what I want

[rwelshjr]

this guy sums it up pretty well. I can just set a base to a 3 star so that way I get what I want

Yeah, there is no argument against that logic. Simply a statement of reality. That's why that guy started getting mad that people would say such things that he couldn't argue with.

[Medici]

Close or invite only. Sounds like clan management issue.