Should Clan War Donation's Count Towards War Loot?

[Spurs978]

If this was the case whole clan would be leader to get more loot

Not only the leaders and co leaders would get the bonus loot. Everyone who donates to the war CC's would get a refund or partial refund

[mtommy2597]

Maybe a small percentage of troop cost wouldn't be bad. Like 30% or maybe it would vary based on the troop.

[GDownage]

Helllo please read this and this as well as the search function before posting.

On topic: no because donating in war clan castles is part of teamwork, encouraging you to win wars, and get that bonus

3 things:

1. My Main idea about partial refunding of the Elixer for Clan War Troop Donations isn't on any of the ruled out links (I already checked this before posting).

2. I cannot find any threads on the search feed, alike to mine.

3. Megalomania make the perfect point in this quote below about War Donation's Regarding Teamwork, plus Teamwork is about sharing better troops for weaker members in the clan as well, so why should only the people able to provide good troops be disadvantage by spending millions of elixer each clan war?

How is it teamwork when only a few have anything to lose?

[GDownage]

I still disagree. The cost of donating troops is the price you pay to win. Just like the military can spend more to add an M203 to every M4 carried by every soldier . . . or maybe save some $$$ and only add them to a few hoping that's all they will need. Do we replace the Apache with new Comanche's or simply upgrade the existing fleet with to Longbows?

You don't HAVE to put the best troops possible in your war castles. But the clans that are dedicated to winning do. It is one of the things that separates the winners (not the ch3@ting ones) from the losers. They try harder and spend more. I think it would be wrong to artificially benefit clans with less dedication so they can be artificially as strong as clans who actually try to be that strong.

I can see your point, but let me show you my imagery as if it was a real war. Firstly, I don't think us [clan members] are the Military, we are more the soldiers going in to fight the war. Now, do Soldier's pay for all their gear for War? No it is provided to them by the Military. So back to Clash of Clans Terms, that would mean some members [soldiers] fighting in the War would be paying for their own gear and the rest of the soldiers gear, which really doesn't seem fair at all if are talking about the fairness of people providing good troops for the rest of the clan.

Hopefully this is not to confusing lol, but that is how my head is thinking in regards to a real life scenario such as yours

[Spurs978]

For higher level army compositions people barely even make a profit with just the cost of the spells and troops to raid (except gold obviously). If you tack on all the expensive cc troop cost a few higher level members that are donating actually start losing elixir. This might not be a problem for those that have all maxed troops and heroes but for others it's a problem. As I said before I think a full refund is too generous but just a small percentage could be fine to help recoup a little cost

[GDownage]

For higher level army compositions people barely even make a profit with just the cost of the spells and troops to raid (except gold obviously). If you tack on all the expensive cc troop cost a few higher level members that are donating actually start losing elixir. This might not be a problem for those that have all maxed troops and heroes but for others it's a problem. As I said before I think a full refund is too generous but just a small percentage could be fine to help recoup a little cost

Yes, this is exactly what I mean, maybe not all loot refunded back, but some so Leaders/Co/Elders can actually make a profit during war, the main issue i find in helping out with CW Troop Donations is that I'm making so much of a loss that I find it hard to keep up with some of my Elixer upgrades

[MommySnooks]

SO! When this thread came out offering some kind of extra loot to replace the huge amounts of loot lost in donations for war. I say YES!!!! Anyone who votes against this is someone who doesn't do the donating in war. OH! And what if you lose the war. Spent 3 to 4 mil elix to win 200k. The more I talk about it. War is really way too expensive to be worth doing for loot. If you win the war, the game should keep up with those donating the most and try and give some of that back.[/QUOTE]

It should count because a. You are TECHINALLY donating troops to someones CC, and b. its costing elixir to make this troops for your teamates.

Unique idea, but no.
When you donate to a clanmate (non-war), you don't get the elixir back. Why should wars be any different?

Why should it be different? In regular play you get a clan castle full of donations for every one to maybe four you fill. In war, our high players regularly train 100 wizards for cc and 20 dragons plus dark troops by request. They only get three clan castles full back (war cc and two attack ones). The cost is forcing players to choose between doing wars, which people want to do, or upgrades. (Because we are all busy and can't play full-time.) So guys with high troops often want to war less, while others who break even if we lose or gain if we win, still want to war more. Creates tension.

[GDownage]

Why should it be different? In regular play you get a clan castle full of donations for every one to maybe four you fill. In war, our high players regularly train 100 wizards for cc and 20 dragons plus dark troops by request. They only get three clan castles full back (war cc and two attack ones). The cost is forcing players to choose between doing wars, which people want to do, or upgrades. (Because we are all busy and can't play full-time.) So guys with high troops often want to war less, while others who break even if we lose or gain if we win, still want to war more. Creates tension.

Exactly! Why should people who donate during clan war be disadvantaged by receiving a major loss every time the Clan goes to War, win or lose usually the War Loot is not enough to cover Elixer Spent during War, only people who actually donate during war actually get this because it is us which are being disadvantaged in trying to help out our clan, even if we get enough back so we can make a little bit of Profit if we win the war would be good.

[choczombie]

Top players donating max dark troops to everyone in the clan cop a massive loss on dark elixir win, draw, or lose. That's donating to war CC, donating to normal CC in anticipation of war attacks, as well as raids using high level dark troops.

[divyam121]

you donate in war, so your clan can win. not just to improve your donations. if a person is good xlasher and really wants their clan to succeed, he will donate in war clan castle without caring for donations .