Opt in or out of clan war with war status button

[Gravitos]

I liked how you are gifted with graphics. If you could make the button on the clan page that would be a cool pictue. I would use it as I continue to push this idea.

Also, in my idea I speak to the topic of 2 ways folks have though how a leader would abuse the button against members wishes if you want to check those. (Why one way is just the leader shooting himself in the foot so its not likely to happen. the other way its really his right and still nicer than kicking)

There you go. I added a graphic with buttons for leaders. I'm not sure if that's what you had in mind, but perhaps it will work for now.

[Gravitos]

This is how we do it and if we have players who don't use their battles. But are otherwise loyal members kick them before war search and reinvite them immediately after using their kicked link

This is the same problem that just about every clan suffers from and I hope that we can get some traction on the opt in /opt out concept to ease the pain of dealing with this issue. Thanks for the reply.

[rwelshjr]

There you go. I added a graphic with buttons for leaders. I'm not sure if that's what you had in mind, but perhaps it will work for now.

As long as the leader has the choice to avoid having to kick I am not going to quibble over button arrangement. Its the concept that's important.

There is another guy here that is seeking such a feature but he wants to be able to swap guys in and our during the war. I have been telling him that any selection has to take place prior to matching but he really wants to be able to change members after that. (he has a problem with guys leaving or refusing to fix a bad base)

[BattleBorn007]

As long as the leader has the choice to avoid having to kick I am not going to quibble over button arrangement. Its the concept that's important.

There is another guy here that is seeking such a feature but he wants to be able to swap guys in and our during the war. I have been telling him that any selection has to take place prior to matching but he really wants to be able to change members after that. (he has a problem with guys leaving or refusing to fix a bad base)

You are the All PowerFul Overseer Of the Opt Out Idea lol

[Gravitos]

As long as the leader has the choice to avoid having to kick I am not going to quibble over button arrangement. Its the concept that's important.

There is another guy here that is seeking such a feature but he wants to be able to swap guys in and our during the war. I have been telling him that any selection has to take place prior to matching but he really wants to be able to change members after that. (he has a problem with guys leaving or refusing to fix a bad base)

Switching people in and out during war can't work. You have to make your selection prior to war search. Once preparation day has started, each clan has to be locked in otherwise, the war star count could vary and that simply wouldn't work.

Plus, I think the biggest complaint by developers at SC is that they don't want to add complexity to the design. The design I have illustrated is super simple and I think would meet the needs of everyone experiencing this problem, which consists of 100% of all clans. I don't think you can make it much simpler than the way I have outlined it. The devs have also stated that they want to encourage 100% participation in your clans activities, but that's unrealistic because not everyone can participate in wars 100% of the time for varying reasons such as not enough elixer resources to build a war army, personal life reasons like studying or work responsibilities, plus 1000 other reasons.

Having to kick people will continue to be the modus operandi and that ads a lot of complexity to managing a clan that wars always. So the fact remains that some kind of solution needs to be put in place to handle this problem.

[alextolomei]

Hey All!




Let me know your thoughts on this idea. Thanks!

I completely agree on everything written.


this is what is lacking in our clan

[Gravitos]

I completely agree on everything written.


this is what is lacking in our clan

Thanks for chiming in.

[rwelshjr]

Switching people in and out during war can't work. You have to make your selection prior to war search. Once preparation day has started, each clan has to be locked in otherwise, the war star count could vary and that simply wouldn't work.

Plus, I think the biggest complaint by developers at SC is that they don't want to add complexity to the design. The design I have illustrated is super simple and I think would meet the needs of everyone experiencing this problem, which consists of 100% of all clans. I don't think you can make it much simpler than the way I have outlined it. The devs have also stated that they want to encourage 100% participation in your clans activities, but that's unrealistic because not everyone can participate in wars 100% of the time for varying reasons such as not enough elixer resources to build a war army, personal life reasons like studying or work responsibilities, plus 1000 other reasons.

Having to kick people will continue to be the modus operandi and that ads a lot of complexity to managing a clan that wars always. So the fact remains that some kind of solution needs to be put in place to handle this problem.

Agreed on all, especially complexity. My own approach I posted does keep complexity down by leveraging existing stuff and functionality as much as possible.

The guy that wants it to be possible after war starts is out to lunch. He is seeking not just a more convenient tool then kick/invite but an actual rules change.

[QueenBeeq]

Yes yes and yes! Everyone but like 3 people wants this!

[Phil01274]

I'd buy that for a dollar...Great idea, I too have to kick and re-invite.