Good clans donate, bad clans don't. Nothing is broken here and there is absolutely no reason to encourage something, that is successfully achieved on a regular basis.
Good clans donate, bad clans don't. Nothing is broken here and there is absolutely no reason to encourage something, that is successfully achieved on a regular basis.
Don't agree entirely there Stan, people not wanting to donate to a mapped war clan castle because it doesn't count towards anything doesn't make them bad players.. they may have more sense than us poor souls. So happy to hear, your clan seems to be the only clan without an issue regarding those donationsOriginally Posted by StanHC
We are a level 5 clan with over 129 war wins, believe me I've fought a few, donating towards the mapped war cc's tend to get tedious and is heavy on the purse, even more so if the war is lost... Although the noddy badge and general thank you is always given, I just thought it would be better if those players could actually gain something by giving up their time and resources to fellow clan members.
Ofc, it does not make them bad players. If anything, it makes them sensible players, who weigh out pros and cons.
But it still makes a clan to be in bad shape for clan war, does it not? :-)
And people who donate expensive troops for war get in exchange the feeling of awesomeness and faster get those awesome clan perks (lvl5 - is great, btw, gratz).
Wars between highly organized clans end in ties often, it is actually nice to have some additional possibility for a clan to invest some of the hard-earned resources to get a slightly better chance of winning. That's self-sacrifice in favor of your team and that's great. If anything, we need more of this, not less. :-)
P.S. Wizards are a fine defending troop, if somebody goes through the trouble of donating double witches - fine, it's their choice. If anything, it makes cc compositions less predictable for people have to run some expense-effect analysis and guess what, it is good too. :-)
Yes we do need more of those, that's why I suggested the xp solution because that was what the thread was about. The sensible players as we now call them (basically they're just stingy lol) would perhaps be encouraged to also do their part. Feeling of awesomeness is awesome Stan, but loot is loot. Oh - and the witch thing - that was purely as an example which makes me wonder now if you read my initial post in its entirety. Everybody is always screaming xp for mapped war cc's and I had an idea of how to make it feasible, just wanted to share
Yeah, got that. It's sensible, though can't help by think, what will happen to requests of 2 witches that nobody is willing to fill in...
In my opinion, Clan Wars have already two super awesome features: - war loot, which gets secured in cc, thus, easing the pain of expensive upgrades; - and ofc clan perks, which are also awesome enough.
I think, it's much more interesting for clan wars to have current system of no direct reward for donating to war ccs. It's just more fun find people with better understanding of the game. ;-)
I think a good idea would be to get xp for the War Donations. You can remove them and donate again at this moment so it isn't good but why not letting one guy only donating once per CC? ( You can still remove them but won't get troops from the same guy again )
R.I.P in Peperoni
LOOT
✝ 12/10/2015
