Encourage War Clan Castle Donations

[SamHanish]

Ok, Here's the thing, too many players don't donate to war clan castles and it usually falls on a few members that always step up during preparation day. This happens because it's all anonymous. Here is my idea to fix this and is real simple:

• Put in a counter like the friend in need in the players profile (no need to give XP donations)
• You can call it Warrior in need

[BattleBorn007]

Ok, Here's the thing, too many players don't donate to war clan castles and it usually falls on a few members that always step up during preparation day. This happens because it's all anonymous. Here is my idea to fix this and is real simple:

• Put in a counter like the friend in need in the players profile (no need to give XP donations)
• You can call it Warrior in need

This idea has been ruled out by SuperCell you can find Ruled out Ideas in the Stickies
Please read though the stickies before posting to prevent the posting of ruled out ideas
You may also use the search function to find threads asking for the same thing.




Thank You and Welcome To the IFR
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines
If you can not find it in the Ruled Out list I can point it out for you if requested




Good Luck and Clash On

Troop/Barracks Related:
*Customize troop builds = to order, permanent productions, saved queues, etc.
*Queue troop donation notices when offline – display when back online or new interface to see info after
*Show total training time left above barracks
*Show total elixir costs of troops sitting in army camps
*5x or 10x button in troop training screens for faster queuing
*Ability to rearrange barracks queued troops (ex: click/hold slide troop icon first in queue to the middle)
*Modify healers to include healing air troops
*Troop carrier (Trojan horse-like) it moves on its own until damaged, then troops pop out
*Release a hero for every troop type (Some more may come eventually, but not EVERY troop)
*Prepackaged troop clusters = similar to clan castle deployment, but you can load like 50 troop count in 4 different clusters to deploy on offense all at once.
*Have clan war troop donations count towards donation statistics

[SamHanish]

[QUOTE=BattleBorn007;3810514]This idea has been ruled out by SuperCell you can find Ruled out Ideas in the Stickies
Please read though the stickies before posting to prevent the posting of ruled out ideas
You may also use the search function to find threads asking for the same thing.



No everyone asking for XP , I'm asking for a counter on the profile that's it.

[BattleBorn007]

No everyone asking for XP , I'm asking for a counter on the profile that's it.

Thats a donation statistic

[EmeraldRange]

This idea isn't ruled out, you are right.

Supercell doesn't want war donations to count towards the actual donation statistics because (according to the FAQs) they want war donations to be solely to help your clan in war and not for other reasons. They say that the incentive is that without your donations, your clan's defences are worse.

Im not so sure, but I don't think Supercell would be exactly eager to display a stat for war donations either, if the above is truly their reason for ruling out the other similar idea.

[rwelshjr]

Ok, Here's the thing, too many players don't donate to war clan castles and it usually falls on a few members that always step up during preparation day. This happens because it's all anonymous. Here is my idea to fix this and is real simple:

• Put in a counter like the friend in need in the players profile (no need to give XP donations)
• You can call it Warrior in need

A lot of clans ask for only their guys with max level troops to handle all donations. So this would be unfair to the others that are being blocked from those achievements.

And also then some of those other guys would then try to pad their numbers by donating lower troops you did not want them to.

And if a person needs encouragement to do donations the clan needs you should tell him he can find it right out that door there.

And the ability to exploit looms unless they take away the ability to edit cc troops which I hope they never do.

[BattleBorn007]

This idea isn't ruled out, you are right.

Supercell doesn't want war donations to count towards the actual donation statistics because (according to the FAQs) they want war donations to be solely to help your clan in war and not for other reasons. They say that the incentive is that without your donations, your clan's defences are worse.

Im not so sure, but I don't think Supercell would be exactly eager to display a stat for war donations either, if the above is truly their reason for ruling out the other similar idea.

I believe SuperCell doesnt want any War donation statistics is because people can donate have the troops removed then keep donating, pretty much people could have crazy high war donation statistics in no time at all.

[WarrenJames]

It is correct that a few people usually fill the majority of the war bases. I've done that more than a few times myself, mostly because I collect enough resources to pull it off, and then do dragon raids for war. Others do most of it because they have better troops, but is draining.

How about we split the difference. We have a clan rank of like "Marshal" or "War Master" or "War Cheif" and show how much they have filled up war bases, so people know he is doing his job. Can have several of them, each with thier own stats.

Besides for honorary bragging rights, I can't think of any benift for it, besides adding a label to clan members in charge of filling war bases, and properly filling requests.

[rwelshjr]

I am the one that does a lot of it in my clan. But I don't need bragging rights, they know what I am doing d I can brag anytime if I ever did come to feel the need. I really do it because I want the clan to win. Winning is something I will gladly brag about. So for me that win counter is what does the job.

[ChiefCharlie]

I am the one that does a lot of it in my clan. But I don't need bragging rights, they know what I am doing d I can brag anytime if I ever did come to feel the need. I really do it because I want the clan to win. Winning is something I will gladly brag about. So for me that win counter is what does the job.

Well - this idea has been rode to hell on the back of a lava hound, but SuperCell should no longer dismiss our frustration. We also battle with the never ending task of encouraging our members to assist in filling those war cc's, doing back to back wars don't help either so it usually falls on a few... not everyone just satisfied in just the win rwelshjr..

Was reading through the posts and I recon the biggest concern regarding giving xp to war cc donations is that people may donate anything just in order to receive. So my suggestion is that they divide the war cc's into troop slots, displaying an exact troop request (editable by member), for example on 25 cc - One max witch (one slot), Two max balloons (one slot) Three level 6 archers (one slot) and the relevant xp points will only be awarded to someone should they be able to fill the slot precisely.