FedeX333X's idea for CLAN LEVELS!

[cryanj23]

Excellent idea, dude. So well thought out. Looks like you spent quite a bit of time on this

[Scuba061]

Very cool and well thought out idea. It certainly adds more incentive and rewards for building and managing long term clans. However, I do have concerns that would need to be addressed.

First, it's been said, but the higher bonuses are way too OP. A simple adjustment fixes that.

Next, matchmaking would need an overhaul. Lower level clans would be discouraged if matched up against higher level clans. Matchmaking has its issues already and this would compound that problem IMO.

Next, something would need to be done with clan hopping. Hijacking clans would be a problem. Why start a new clan if you could steal a higher level one from some sucker? Perhaps some required time limit to reap the clan bonuses would help this?

Anyway, keep working on this as I think this is a great start for a very cool concept in wars.

[NickDuBois4]

This sounds like a great idea! Hopefully, it is noticed by Supercell

My only complaint is the Attack and Health Bonus. They are pretty OP. I would suggest reducing both of these bonuses by 55 to 60%

[FedeX333X]

Perharps you should make a different reward for winning an attack with 1, 2 or 3 stars, because as it is now, a town hall sniper gets the same xp points as a gowipe raid that ends with 3 stars.
Good idea, I support it! ;-)

Thank you for the idea, Gio 89, this is true, and I will make different rewards in base of the numbers of star obtained

[FedeX333X]

Excellent idea, dude. So well thought out. Looks like you spent quite a bit of time on this

Yes, I have been making the thread since January, it took quite a lot of time to do it

[FedeX333X]

This sounds like a great idea! Hopefully, it is noticed by Supercell

My only complaint is the Attack and Health Bonus. They are pretty OP. I would suggest reducing both of these bonuses by 55 to 60%

I am very happy that the idea has been noticed by Supercell!
As many of you told me, I have reduced the percentages in the attack and health bonus, in order not to make them so Over Powered.

[FedeX333X]

Very cool and well thought out idea. It certainly adds more incentive and rewards for building and managing long term clans. However, I do have concerns that would need to be addressed.

First, it's been said, but the higher bonuses are way too OP. A simple adjustment fixes that.

Next, matchmaking would need an overhaul. Lower level clans would be discouraged if matched up against higher level clans. Matchmaking has its issues already and this would compound that problem IMO.

Next, something would need to be done with clan hopping. Hijacking clans would be a problem. Why start a new clan if you could steal a higher level one from some sucker? Perhaps some required time limit to reap the clan bonuses would help this?

Anyway, keep working on this as I think this is a great start for a very cool concept in wars.

Thank you for your suggestions!
1) About bonuses, I have reduced all of them now, so I think that now they are balanced well
2) About matchmaking, I know it is already a problem, and this is why Clan Levels bonuses are not active in Clan Wars unless the matchmaking system will consider also them.
3) That's true, I didn't thought about that! I think that as you said there should a time limit before any new member can take benefits from the bonuses unlocked by the clan, I'll say 5/7 days. The problem is that this would effect all the people who are already members, but that, for example, need to leave the clan not to do a war, co-leader of big clans that have to visit their academy to see if everything is ok,...
You have discovered two weak points of the idea that must be solved!
Thank you again for telling me your concerns, I'll focus now on how to solve this problems!

[techcare]

About Clan Wars,
- Winning a Clan War will result in 1000 Clan Xp
- Having a tie will result in 250 Clan Xp
- Losing a Clan War will result 100 Clan Xp (even the losers deserve a small prize)

Losers do not deserve anything.

[Sukiawesome]

Great idea!!!! +1!!!

[FedeX333X]

Great idea!!!! +1!!!

Thank you!