Walls and war strength rating

[TheRealchrism]

no second was attacked by th9

Thats funny, because according to his profile and base, he is a TH10...and I don't think, last I checked, I can't get 23 lvl 6 wizards and 3 lvl 5 golem at TH9. But I will go with your "I was attacked by a TH9" theory. Yes, a TH9 did try to attack me, but that was not the replay I was looking at. Same attacker for both of us - ign - wilder clan - Hunter Clan. Another TH10 in their clan attacked the guy below me (a TH9) and got more war loot available than our #1 about 10k less than my total.

[Gama321]

for TH9 our traps, bombs, defense are all maxed
he now has 50 lvl 10 walls, i am all lego's
he has lvl 11 bk, lvl 13 aq, I have lvl 16 both
my troops/spells are all max, he has valk, lava both lvl 1 (all other max)
His in attack 394200 each and 1728 DE, mine 438000 each and 1920 de ( using the x6)

just tells me walls do play a part in map rank

If your base is worth more than his and he is higher than you then it means that you finished some upgrades on prep day, if that's what you meant.

[HeliSmith]

If your base is worth more than his and he is higher than you then it means that you finished some upgrades on prep day, if that's what you meant.

Good point!

[TheRealchrism]

If your base is worth more than his and he is higher than you then it means that you finished some upgrades on prep day, if that's what you meant.

I have had max def/all buildings/traps/troops/bombs/spells for two months (TH9), working solely on lego walls. I had nothing else to upgrade, his finished around the end of the war. He, on all buildings, just finished. He still has troops (valk and lava hound) and hero's to catch up to me. He is ahead of me on lava walls by 50 and has been ahead of me for the last 3 wars on rank. Not complaining, just made me think that walls have more weight than we originally thought. That extra 1500 hp per wall from lvl 9 to lvl 10 may play more of a roll in matching and war rank than we thought overall.

[Gama321]

I have had max def/all buildings/traps/troops/bombs/spells for two months (TH9), working solely on lego walls. I had nothing else to upgrade, his finished around the end of the war. He, on all buildings, just finished. He still has troops (valk and lava hound) and hero's to catch up to me. He is ahead of me on lava walls by 50 and has been ahead of me for the last 3 wars on rank. Not complaining, just made me think that walls have more weight than we originally thought. That extra 1500 hp per wall from lvl 9 to lvl 10 may play more of a roll in matching and war rank than we thought overall.

interesting... no offense but I don't believe you Plus mortar and skel traps haven't been here for two months yet I think, but you probably maxed those by now though...
Only stone cold evidence would convince me, and that would be as soon as prep day begins, a pic of both bases would still work actually, since map placement is directly related to war loot.

But as to what you mean I haven't experienced that and from what some people say high level walls may not have any weighting at all.

[TheRealchrism]

interesting... no offense but I don't believe you Plus mortar and skel traps haven't been here for two months yet I think, but you probably maxed those by now though...
Only stone cold evidence would convince me, and that would be as soon as prep day begins, a pic of both bases would still work actually, since map placement is directly related to war loot.

But as to what you mean I haven't experienced that and from what some people say high level walls may not have any weighting at all.

Maxed out skellys and mortars two weeks after they came out, halloween update, I was maxed until they added them, cut into my wall upgrade effort. Next war, prep day tomorrow, I will take pics of placement and the loot available on war day, provided we both get attacked and by the same level player, since that seems to make a difference, I will post them along with our profile pics so you can see the difference in our bases and troops/hero's (we are both max def now, he just caught up). I have seen several bases ranked lower with more loot available, ya it threw me at first, but after several wars I just said, huh...oh well. Map placement does not seem to have an effect on war loot IMO. I normally see this on rushed bases where a TH9 is lopped in with TH8's or a TH10 mixed with TH9's. King is also stronger in our clan other than walls. The loot difference would explain why the top guy always attacks me first from the enemy clan....

You can look at our bases Clan- Agentofdarkness #92YV8PCR My ign - chrism clanmate - nate

our current war order nate, king, chrism, jackfatty

we have a few maxed TH9 and TH8's (other than hero's and walls)

[unclemercy]

would really like a more definitive answer on this. theories are fun and all but everybody can stuff their i thinks down their sinks. im too lazy tbh but am super surprised no one has reverse engineered a real answer to this by now.

or more likely if they have they just arent sharing.

will subscribe and continue to follow.

[TheRealchrism]

would really like a more definitive answer on this. theories are fun and all but everybody can stuff their i thinks down their sinks. im too lazy tbh but am super surprised no one has reverse engineered a real answer to this by now.

or more likely if they have they just arent sharing.

will subscribe and continue to follow.

I am sure some college kids in the math/science department have and also have a killer war clan.

[cyaspah]

u need to keep in mind that apart from heroes and defense levels, the level of your troops, spells and size of army camps and how upgraded your traps are "invisible" elements that you wont just see straight away by viewing 2 persons villages

[Gama321]

Maxed out skellys and mortars two weeks after they came out, halloween update, I was maxed until they added them, cut into my wall upgrade effort. Next war, prep day tomorrow, I will take pics of placement and the loot available on war day, provided we both get attacked and by the same level player, since that seems to make a difference, I will post them along with our profile pics so you can see the difference in our bases and troops/hero's (we are both max def now, he just caught up). I have seen several bases ranked lower with more loot available, ya it threw me at first, but after several wars I just said, huh...oh well. Map placement does not seem to have an effect on war loot IMO. I normally see this on rushed bases where a TH9 is lopped in with TH8's or a TH10 mixed with TH9's. King is also stronger in our clan other than walls. The loot difference would explain why the top guy always attacks me first from the enemy clan....

You can look at our bases Clan- Agentofdarkness #92YV8PCR My ign - chrism clanmate - nate

our current war order nate, king, chrism, jackfatty

we have a few maxed TH9 and TH8's (other than hero's and walls)

The reason why those rushed bases would be mixed in is due to buildings finishing upgrading or being built, which would be a more common occurrence for rushed bases
Just post a pic of both of your bases from the last war so we can compare it and see why one is worth more than the other, but we would need to see trap levels too
Remember that more loot is given to bases that are tougher, and that map placement is in order of which base is tougher.