"Retry" option for attack practice

[btcc1721]

This is a very good idea and I love the idea of being able to practice attacks. However here are some things to consider...

.........

Let me know if you have any thoughts or arguments. I am always open to new points of view. Good luck in your future clash of clans endeavors.

-m113434

Piece of advice bro, cut down on the length of your forum posts. Most people won't read this, regardless of how good it is.

Also, a lot of what you have said in there is old debates, this thread is just leading on from that.

[edomingox]

I see no practical use for this option. The war is over, whether you retry to see if it works again becomes irrelevant. Like looking at the River card in Texas Hold Em after you folded on the Turn.

[m113434]

Piece of advice bro, cut down on the length of your forum posts. Most people won't read this, regardless of how good it is.

Also, a lot of what you have said in there is old debates, this thread is just leading on from that.

Actually bro, I read through the entire thread and there is nothing even close to my debate. Mostly what everyone is saying is either this is a great idea or it is too exploitable. Nobody has discussed yet how this would effect the skill level of clan wars.

I am trying to present a reasonable argument for why this might not be a good idea. I have laid out in an orderly fashion the logic behind my belief. I think that posts like mine spawn more productive and intellectual discussions than just saying "Great Idea!" or "Too exploitable." People have to discuss new ideas using logic for forums to be productive. Sorry if it was a little lengthy but if people don't wish to discuss how these types of updates will impact the game in a positive or negative way, they don't have to read it. If they do, then we might actually have productive discussions.

[Allybug01]

Love this version of the idea!

[btcc1721]

Actually bro, I read through the entire thread and there is nothing even close to my debate. Mostly what everyone is saying is either this is a great idea or it is too exploitable. Nobody has discussed yet how this would effect the skill level of clan wars.

I am trying to present a reasonable argument for why this might not be a good idea. I have laid out in an orderly fashion the logic behind my belief. I think that posts like mine spawn more productive and intellectual discussions than just saying "Great Idea!" or "Too exploitable." People have to discuss new ideas using logic for forums to be productive. Sorry if it was a little lengthy but if people don't wish to discuss how these types of updates will impact the game in a positive or negative way, they don't have to read it. If they do, then we might actually have productive discussions.

I was referring to old threads, not earlier on in this thread.

Also, long posts often just lead to TLDR, by everyone.

[Allybug01]

I see no practical use for this option. The war is over, whether you retry to see if it works again becomes irrelevant. Like looking at the River card in Texas Hold Em after you folded on the Turn.

Most people here probably don't know anything much about poker.
Its to practice attacks, how to improve and get tips on how to do it better and then try it out so you will know better for next time.

[btcc1721]

Folks seem to have lost the purpose of this brilliant idea. You have ONE attempt while the replay is still available to attack YOUR base which you have already done so, maybe only one 'retry' every 12 hours. This is no m0dding or h@cking, it is a way of finding out why your attack went potentially so badly wrong. If you look at the credibility of some of the people who support this idea, you'll realise how good it is.

[btcc1721]

You sure you want this m0d ♥♥♥♥ to find it's way into the game?
Because that is what you are suggesting, the things you are talking about are allready out there for j4ilbreaked divices.

Endless offline practice on a warbase, specific resource amount searchring, spell checker and lots more loser stuff.
Where is the skill in that?

It takes away form the moment, the unsuspected, the kinda thing that makes this game interesting for me.
Bad idea, very, very bad idea. Even worse actually!

But hey, on the other hand, SuperCell isn't doing anything to stop this rampant ch34ting...
If you can't beat em, join em?

Cheers dude.

Please read through the whole thread, which you have clearly not done so. You'll see these issues have been addressed and fixed.

[m113434]

I was referring to old threads, not earlier on in this thread.

Also, long posts often just lead to TLDR, by everyone.

So you don't think the details of this idea are worth discussing? Because it is impossible to do an in depth analysis without writing more than a couple sentences. People who are actually interested in the idea will read and respond. People who aren't will skip over it.

[btcc1721]

So you don't think the details of this idea are worth discussing? Because it is impossible to do an in depth analysis without writing more than a couple sentences. People who are actually interested in the idea will read and respond. People who aren't will skip over it.

In depth analysis doesn't come in the form of uber long posts. I'm not going to continue this pointless debate, it's wasting space on this thread.