Stop free shields from th snipes.

[Spurs978]

If the reward for th sniping is zero loot. Th only victory is zero trophies. That would sort the issue. No gain for sniping so players wouldn't do it. Trophies would be for 2 star plus victories. Loot obviously would be raided. Need 2 stars for victory bonus. 👍👍

Are you saying they should take away trophies from one stars??

[ROM4N]

Are you saying they should take away trophies from one stars??

It would reduce th only shields. Thsts why I started this post. Obviously the loot amounts were drastic.

[Spurs978]

So if people who are trophy pushing at higher cup offers only get a one star they basically wasted an entire expensive army? They didn't do a perfect raid but they still deserve some reward for this. You have to look at how this would affect everyone at different trophy ranges and farming or pushing...

[ROM4N]

So if people who are trophy pushing at higher cup offers only get a one star they basically wasted an entire expensive army? They didn't do a perfect raid but they still deserve some reward for this

Th only would result in zero trophies. 50% destruction would remain the same

[Spurs978]

Th only would result in zero trophies. 50% destruction would remain the same

And if someone gets a 40 percent one star?

[Xitra]

Your idea is ruled out (increase storage capacity in town halls) + Supercell would lose a lot of members, me included. How am I supposed to upgrade my village with a town hall inside my base? And hybrid bases are bad.

Actually, it's not ruled out. It's in the section for commonly requested features.

Other Buildings Related:
* Add decoy buildings that still get targeted by troops, but yield nothing (fake mine/cannon)
- - - - - - - - - -
* Increase Town Hall resource storage incrementally by level, perhaps 1/2/3/4/5/10/20/30/40/50k?
* Dark Spell Factory for defensive spells - build with dark elixir
* Add a boost option for builders (work at 4x speed for X number of hours)

[ROM4N]

And if someone gets a 40 percent one star?

40% isn't 1 star now. No need to change that

[Spurs978]

40% isn't 1 star now. No need to change that

If they get the th but don't get 50 percent...

[Goobers]

If the reward for th sniping is zero loot. Th only victory is zero trophies. That would sort the issue. No gain for sniping so players wouldn't do it. Trophies would be for 2 star plus victories. Loot obviously would be raided. Need 2 stars for victory bonus.

Not zero loot, just a lot less from the result of a reformed league bonus system. Trophies would remain unaffected, as they are already star-based.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...nus-multiplier

1-star: % of league bonus rewarded based on % damage dealt to base
2-star: 100% league bonus rewarded
3-star: multiplier applied to league bonus

This would mean that a 2% 1-star TH snipe up in Master 3 would pay out 2k/2k/10 instead of 100k/100k/500. Very little incentive to simply stop at sniping the TH other than to move up in trophies. But again, why move up in trophies unless you plan on 2-starring bases for the full league bonus? That's why it works.

So if people who are trophy pushing at higher cup offers only get a one star they basically wasted an entire expensive army? They didn't do a perfect raid but they still deserve some reward for this. You have to look at how this would affect everyone at different trophy ranges and farming or pushing...

Th only would result in zero trophies. 50% destruction would remain the same

And if someone gets a 40 percent one star?

Yeah see I don't support what Roman here is saying.

A TH snipe is still a win as it fills the necessary requirement which is "getting the TH for 1 star." You would still be rewarded 1/3 of the available trophies. None of that is affected. It's simply the way the league bonuses are paid out which is changed. In your case, a 40% 1-star would get 40% of the league bonus. If they managed to get 50% and the TH, then they get the full league bonus.

Obviously we can see from this that more often than not, 1-stars will be happening far more often than 3-stars, so the lesser league bonuses will outweigh the multipliers. You simply increase league bonuses across the board again to adjust for this on a macro-economic level. The only difference is that more loot is rewarded to players who provide tougher attacks, in the form of 2- and 3-stars.

[AxionXD]

Even if u do put ur th inside if it's taken out u will still lose an insane amount of loot. The poll speaks for itself. This just isn't a feasible fix to the problem. Maybe with less loot available. Farming has become part of the game. No need to change it...

Losing 350k of Gold is reasonable, a lot more reasonable than losing 850k of gold, come on, you are more than DOUBLING the available loot with your idea.

If you give more rewards for the TH, you'll give more incentive to snipe.

If you give TOO much rewards for the TH, you'll destroy the game.

Your idea is treading in dangerous waters my friend...

You worry about the available loot out there, but forget how much of YOUR loot becomes more available. Right now, I feel there's still a good balance. If your idea, with the numbers you've presented, were to be implemented.... well, it would destroy the game. No one would be able to play the game casually as every time you log off, you'll more than likely get raided for all of your loot.... 850k of each, 8k of DE.... so those that raid and log off would never be able to play ever again

The only ones able to play are the ones that can stay logged on for 6 hour straight to play without getting raided.