4 star clan war system

[Skenderbeu]

I think a half star system would be easier for SC to implement, for example:

Destroy
25% Get half a star
50% Get an additional half a star (1 Star)
75% Get an additional half a star (1 and a Half Stars)
100% Get an additional half a star (2 Stars)

You still get 1 star for destroying a town hall and obviously wont get 100% without destroying it as well (3 Stars)

So if you destroy 90% of a base but not the town hall you get 1 and a half stars.

If you destroy 90% with the town hall you get 2 and a half stars.

You get 3 stars for destroying 100% (2 Stars) and the town hall (+1 star)

Make Sense?

i dont think this is a good idea! If thay change the system it should be smth very similar to a 4 star in my opinion

[boss1986]

Your threads my friend are very actual and i supprt them both!

[Dpmoton]

I like it. It's a good idea

[Daderpysir]

New type of wall/Troop SUPERCELL WORKERS PLEASE READ

I believe that "pits" could be a possible new defense that will get popular fast it would be called a "pit" it wouldn't be an upgrade of a wall it would be a new type of defense and its roll would be like a wall; to defend your village, it would be a 1x1 pit of lava that could be added together and moved like walls, the only way to get passed it is by flying troops or a bridger, a bridger is the next idea i have that goes with the "pit", the bridger is my idea of a new dark barrack troop, it would have as many as 150 hit points and no dps, its a skeleton running/holding a wide wood plank in front of him, once he reaches a pit (lava pit) he will lay down the wood plank, and walla now your ground troops can get over the pit (lava pit)!

[Keepo]

You realise that this would be the same/worse? The ratio of max stars:stars acquired is effectively the same, if you get over 75%. However, more stars would be lost for those who cannot get that.

[Seuss145]

Yes please, 2 star has become too easy for many levels from maxed th8+, implementing this might make it a little complicated, but will make the use of more stragety in clan wars. I go for 50% 2 stars, but now will have to go for 75% 3 stars.

[Skenderbeu]

New type of wall/Troop SUPERCELL WORKERS PLEASE READ

I believe that "pits" could be a possible new defense that will get popular fast it would be called a "pit" it wouldn't be an upgrade of a wall it would be a new type of defense and its roll would be like a wall; to defend your village, it would be a 1x1 pit of lava that could be added together and moved like walls, the only way to get passed it is by flying troops or a bridger, a bridger is the next idea i have that goes with the "pit", the bridger is my idea of a new dark barrack troop, it would have as many as 150 hit points and no dps, its a skeleton running/holding a wide wood plank in front of him, once he reaches a pit (lava pit) he will lay down the wood plank, and walla now your ground troops can get over the pit (lava pit)!

AHhahah i would prefer to receive your opinion for my proposal!!

[Skenderbeu]

You realise that this would be the same/worse? The ratio of max stars:stars acquired is effectively the same, if you get over 75%. However, more stars would be lost for those who cannot get that.

YES! That`s the point. This aim to make a difference from an attack that gets barely 51% 2 stars from an attack thats nearly destroys 100% the opponent.

[Megalomania]

I agree with the 4 star idea. There's a HUGE difference between a 51% attack and a 99% attack and the current system ignores that. It's definitely a better indicator of how good/bad your attack was.

[Yardey]

i dont think this is a good idea! If thay change the system it should be smth very similar to a 4 star in my opinion

With 4 stars you have to change the whole game, where as 3 stars rewarded in halves means you only have to modify it.