Rejected Ideas

[Jer4Bear]

I just went through the ideas sticky supercell listed of the good ideas the forum had and then the list that has been rejected by supercell. My question is why were they rejected ideas? Some of the ideas rejected are ideas I personally have been wondering and others seem to be extremely simple and innocent ideas that could add depth to this game. I wont specify which ideas due to the simple fact, it doesn't matter which, but I would really like some sort of understanding as to why a lot of the ideas were rejected by supercell.

I do absolutely understand there is a business side to this game and since its a free game with in app purchases, some of the rejected ideas are due to money aspects. I understand and respect that fact, those are not the ones I am concerned with.

[Ramirez2431]

Ask this in general they'll give you an answer

[Jer4Bear]

Ask this in general they'll give you an answer

Has this been answered before? I don't intend on beating a dead horse.

[TheOutrageousPuffin]

Has this been answered before? I don't intend on beating a dead horse.

Welcome to the forum! Yes, they have, possibly thousands of times. If you would like to know you can use the handy search button and search for the ideas and find sarcastic and mean answers as to why the ideas are ruled out.
Hope you enjoy your time on the forum😊

[Jer4Bear]

Welcome to the forum! Yes, they have, possibly thousands of times. If you would like to know you can use the handy search button and search for the ideas and find sarcastic and mean answers as to why the ideas are ruled out.
Hope you enjoy your time on the forum😊

I'm looking for supercell responses, not sarcastic members in the forums speculation on why they are rejected.

[George1971]

I'm looking for supercell responses, not sarcastic members in the forums speculation on why they are rejected.

SuperCell are not active here. Just people presuming to speak on their behalf.

[Gama321]

I'm looking for supercell responses, not sarcastic members in the forums speculation on why they are rejected.

They dont have to give reasons, and they generally dont. However most of them are common sense and forumers would be able to tell you.

[EmeraldRange]

Supercell doesn't really give reasons and they try to not interact with these conversations, but just watch and take ideas, but they are active and watching.

Long time ago, some senior members of the forum got together and compiled a list of reasons why those ideas might be ruled out. (http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...uled-out-ideas)

[George1971]

Supercell doesn't really give reasons and they try to not interact with these conversations, but just watch and take ideas, but they are active and watching.

Long time ago, some senior members of the forum got together and compiled a list of reasons why those ideas might be ruled out. (http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...uled-out-ideas)

Is that like a statement of religious faith?

I think they have forgotten this place.

[mmf01]

Supercell doesn't really give reasons and they try to not interact with these conversations, but just watch and take ideas, but they are active and watching.

Long time ago, some senior members of the forum got together and compiled a list of reasons why those ideas might be ruled out. (http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...uled-out-ideas)

To the OP: Thank you for reading the sticky!

The link above are the best reasons that we know put together by some forumers and a few mods.