The Single BEST IDEA EVER FOR CLASH!!!!!!!

[ArcticWolf130]

Sorry about that title... Had to get you to click some how. Recently everyone has been getting on the revenge system... so why not just make it like war?

The problem
People can't revenge enough because of the shields and people being online. There is also the issue of being attacked for 300k loot and then revenging and only being offered 50k loot.

The Solution
First things first. The online and shielding problems. To fix this is simple. Every time you press the revenge button a revenge request will be sent to that person and if they accept then you can revenge them. I know what your thinking... Why would I invite someone to destroy my base? The answer is simple. For loot.

Basically the way revenge will work is, to win the revenge you must two star or destroy the TH. If they destroy the th then the attacker gets the loot that was offered (like war) and you lose nothing but trophies for excepting the request. If they fail to destroy the th then you get the loot that was offered to them for destroying your TH. This makes it so there is no loss in excepting a revenge request. Sure, you may lose some trophies if they wreck your base, but because its like war and the loot is not your own then whats the harm.

Basically by excepting a revenge you can only gain with nothing to lose. There is a chance you will get loot if they fail and there is a chance they will get loot if they win.

High Risk, High Reward (Optional, Not part of the main idea).
So what happens if they get a three star. This is optional and if this is a bad part of the idea then tell me (because this part feels iffy). So if they three star I was thinking they get the loot offered and whats in your base. This wouldn't be a normal revenge. There would be an optional button to press called something like high stakes revenge. If you don't three star then they get the offered loot and what ever is in your base... Without even attacking. So be careful with high stakes revenge. Its up to you to send the request and them to except it so if you both consent to high stakes it no one but your own fault what happens.

At any point you have 2 hours to except a revenge request.

EDIT: The pole glitched out on me so I need you to say if its good or bad?

[BattleBorn007]

Im not fond of the idea soooo no

[MigBelt08]

I like the "kick them off if they're just sitting there" idea better.

[ArcticWolf130]

I like the "kick them off if they're just sitting there" idea better.

I kinda don't like that though because if you a pusher then you basically get crushed every time you attack someone.

[rwelshjr]

I think its certainly better than the other ideas that I have seen come across. Just needs a little more work.The issue is that you can't have SC footing any of the bill here or they would not do it. So balance out where the payouts come from, the person getting revenged can lose loot, but they can also get even more if it goes for them.

In defense to those guys that like revenge as it is today I wonder if there should be revenge as normal so that does not get disrupted, and a then 'challenge to duel' option to go with it.

BTW - Your title actually came close to making me skip by it since we see 'best ever' stuff all day every day. That just becomes noise after a while. I am glad I said what the heck and checked since the idea wasn't stupid like I was first assuming.

[MigBelt08]

I kinda don't like that though because if you a pusher then you basically get crushed every time you attack someone.

How is that different than revenging if they're offline?

[ArcticWolf130]

How is that different than revenging if they're offline?

Because you can choose if you wanna accept the revenge or not. So if your pushing and cant afford to lose trophies just except them later.

[rwelshjr]

Because you can choose if you wanna accept the revenge or not. So if your pushing and cant afford to lose trophies just except them later.

So how long do they have to accept? That's actually a good point that needs to get covered.

[ArcticWolf130]

So how long do they have to accept? That's actually a good point that needs to get covered.

I said about two hours but if you think a different time would be better please tell me.

[rwelshjr]

I said about two hours but if you think a different time would be better please tell me.

No, 2 hours is god. Sorry, I missed that part.

I think you have a cool idea but instead of replacing the current revenge instead be an option for a duel off. Maybe they compete double or nothing for what was taken. If either does not have left the amount of any given resource that was taken the other gets what they do have. (and also that person can only win that amount back so no one stands to win than then can give away in the duel. even bet for an amount set before the duel. And nothing is taken during the duel ether, its about stars. And so guys sending to get ready for their duel will be money in SCs pocket which gives it a chance.

These are just my thoughts. My support is because I think you are onto a cool concept so continue to shape it.

it would be good for more guys to weigh in with more smart thoughts than I gave.