Clan War idea - leavers not getting back in!

[jontylikeskk]

This came to me this evening when playing against another clan that had 3 members leave their clan once the battle had started / the clan prep started. Being relatively new to the clan wars and not having seen this before, I believed that these clan members would NOT be able to participate in the war. however with little time left in the war the two members re-joined the clan and then battled.

This was clearly a ploy and a way to misuse the system and is perhaps a bug that needs to be ironed out, as my belief was that on joining a clan you should only be eligible for participating in a war after 48 hours, at least.

Please can you fix it so that if a clan member leaves a clan and then re-joins they HAVE to wait at least 48 hours before they can battle, even if they were in the war when it started and then left.

The third one from their clan left right at the start of preparation and tried to join our clan, something I have seen before and he was immediately rejected. Some said that this was to join us and to get us to donate and use up resources, or to simply spy on us and check out what sort of threat they were facing. Either way when he was rejected and then re-joined his clan he was able to battle, in my view this must be stopped by preventing them from battling during the current war.

In summary, if they leave during a war, AT ANY POINT, they shouldn't be able to battle in it, AT ALL!

[TEGU]

Never assume they aren't going to battle. Also never assume they aren't going to raid just cause they left ...some players will leave their clan in hopes of getting stronger troops for war through donating clans or maybe a friends clan. No need to change much here in my opinion.
In any case ... Never assume.

[rwelshjr]

This came to me this evening when playing against another clan that had 3 members leave their clan once the battle had started / the clan prep started. Being relatively new to the clan wars and not having seen this before, I believed that these clan members would NOT be able to participate in the war. however with little time left in the war the two members re-joined the clan and then battled.

This was clearly a ploy and a way to misuse the system and is perhaps a bug that needs to be ironed out, as my belief was that on joining a clan you should only be eligible for participating in a war after 48 hours, at least.

Please can you fix it so that if a clan member leaves a clan and then re-joins they HAVE to wait at least 48 hours before they can battle, even if they were in the war when it started and then left.

The third one from their clan left right at the start of preparation and tried to join our clan, something I have seen before and he was immediately rejected. Some said that this was to join us and to get us to donate and use up resources, or to simply spy on us and check out what sort of threat they were facing. Either way when he was rejected and then re-joined his clan he was able to battle, in my view this must be stopped by preventing them from battling during the current war.

In summary, if they leave during a war, AT ANY POINT, they shouldn't be able to battle in it, AT ALL!

Quite the opposite. If a person leaves you are hoping they will come back.

And yeah, watch out for spies. Just don't let them in. Or let them in and feed them disinformation, whatever you are happier with. Either way its fair and ;legal and your job to deal with them.