****clan members should be able to avenge an attack on other clan members****

[BriteEyezz]

ive been attacked by players much stronger than me at times. So I think that if you're in a clan you should be able to post the attack in the clan chat and one member from your clan should be able to hit revenge and be able to avenge the attack if you happen to not be strong enough and they are. Just like the donation bar when a member hits revenge it should disappear from the chat and that way we defend each other. Isn't that the point of being in a clan anyway?? Just saying

[mmf01]

First of all, I wouldn't see this happening considering it may be a large waste of elixir. There would have to be some type of large loot bonus especially since it's very possible that the 'revenged base' doesn't have much loot available.

With this idea, I could see a lot of people making 'Revenge & Go' clans...

Lastly, if you're a th3/4/5, and you attacked someone similar to you, a th8/9/10 could just absolutely annihilate your base.

To me, clans are about donations, that's what Supercell mentions about clans. To give each other 'reinforcements'. Even clan wars to me is not a top priority of clans.

[John27S]

I think that's a great idea I recon it would encourage stronger clan bonds and be abit of fun
of course there will be people who try take advantage of a way to get more resources so maybe have it so you would have to have been in a clan for a week before you can take revenge that would probably make it too much of a hassle for people trying to take advantage

[DragoonXV]

I think that's a great idea I recon it would encourage stronger clan bonds and be abit of fun
of course there will be people who try take advantage of a way to get more resources so maybe have it so you would have to have been in a clan for a week before you can take revenge that would probably make it too much of a hassle for people trying to take advantage

ive been attacked by players much stronger than me at times. So I think that if you're in a clan you should be able to post the attack in the clan chat and one member from your clan should be able to hit revenge and be able to avenge the attack if you happen to not be strong enough and they are. Just like the donation bar when a member hits revenge it should disappear from the chat and that way we defend each other. Isn't that the point of being in a clan anyway?? Just saying

I believe not only is this idea ruled out, its stupid. Imagine! Then every clan would send their revenges to their strongest clan member! AND BESIDES! The whole point of revenge is getting your loot back and trophies. Not smashing the other person's base. Who would receive the loot? Obviously not you because you didn't do anything. The attacker in your clan would. Besides, think about the game overall. Horrible. Please you two, think for the sake of mankind, we ate from the Tree of Knowledge. We should have brains.

[TFountain]

I tried to make a detailed reply on how I would like to see this work, but my shoddy internet connection probably messed it up.

The point I tried to make is that there are already systems in place in the game that make this very possible, and I don't think it would take much for a seamless rollout.

It isn't all about loot, sometimes people just want to lash out with their clash out.

[MigBelt08]

You get attacked by a th5 right? So you get a maxed th10 to get revenge for you right? #gamebreaking

Edit: Not necessarily gamebreaking. Totally unfair is a better way to put it. Might make people stop playing which could break the game in the long run.

[TheFirstSteven]

ive been attacked by players much stronger than me at times. So I think that if you're in a clan you should be able to post the attack in the clan chat and one member from your clan should be able to hit revenge and be able to avenge the attack if you happen to not be strong enough and they are. Just like the donation bar when a member hits revenge it should disappear from the chat and that way we defend each other. Isn't that the point of being in a clan anyway?? Just saying

Public hitlist??? ruled out...

[TFountain]

The idea that would work:

A red 'Avenge' icon in the chat bar, similar to sharing replays.

A time delay between posting for Vengeance, similar to the replay share delay.

A comment in the chat bar saying 'yyy has Avenged xxx'.

Reduced loot for Avenge, similar to using a level 10 town hall to attack a level 3 town hall.

An Avenge counter similar to the troop donate/receive counter in the clan menu.


Other ideas that would take more effort or might not work:

Allowing 'Avenge' attacks even while shield is active.

Putting a cap on the loot to max out at what was stolen in the first place.

Sending a message to the Avengee, 'your attack on xxx was avenged by yyy'.

Putting zero loot on Avenge attacks.

[BattleBorn007]

This is beyond a bad idea, you would have th10s from one clan destroying lower levels why? Because you arnt able to revenge the player yourself?

[TheFirstSteven]

The idea that would work:

A red 'Avenge' icon in the chat bar, similar to sharing replays.

A time delay between posting for Vengeance, similar to the replay share delay.

A comment in the chat bar saying 'yyy has Avenged xxx'.

Reduced loot for Avenge, similar to using a level 10 town hall to attack a level 3 town hall.

An Avenge counter similar to the troop donate/receive counter in the clan menu.


Other ideas that would take more effort or might not work:

Allowing 'Avenge' attacks even while shield is active.

Putting a cap on the loot to max out at what was stolen in the first place.

Sending a message to the Avengee, 'your attack on xxx was avenged by yyy'.

Putting zero loot on Avenge attacks.

its ruled out dude u don't need to keep discussing a ruled out Idea