allow troops to survive

[steelersrock]

Dear Supercell,
I think it would be a very good idea to change clash of clans to where if you are in a battle and you win the battle and some troops survive you get to keep the troops. They do this in boom beach and it is a good idea because it is frustrating when you spend lots of elixir on a troop lie a pekka or dragon, and then they survive the battle but you lose them.

[HiJacked]

Here's an idea... play Boom Beach.

[TheMan131505]

This would be a problem when a low leveled player is donated, let's say, a level 4 dragon or valkyrie. It would probably never die if they used it properly and then that troop could cause havoc for a lot of battles.

I do think this could work if they made it so tier 2 and 3 troops disappeared but if any barbarians, archers, goblins or minions survived the battle they could remain to fight another day.

[JJason]

Ruled out! Please read the stickies before posting a request!


And anyways, BB already has this feature.

[mhed]

no just no then we can use mass dragon over and over again

[Sirix]

Ruled out! Please read the stickies before posting a request!


And anyways, BB already has this feature.

It hasn't been ruled out for a while which was shortly after elixir walls were added.
A partial refund (20% or less) would be better so that people can't attack continuously and make people not want to boost

[shiranai]

Just because it works in one SC game doesn't mean it would work in another.

The thing is raiding is one of the things that keep the elixir economy in motion. Raiding means training troops. Training troops means spending elixir. If you keep surviving troops you have to only train what you lost, and in turn spend less elixir. This will eventually result in a(nother) surplus of unwanted elixir and the accompanying forum threads that complain about it.