Forfeit button for clan leaders

[PepsiKing123]

This is not a good idea. period. the first thing i thought of is that now that clans can create clan wars with other clans by using their codes, clans will set the wars up so that after waiting the time, one clan can quit right away. Easy loot bonus for another clan if the guy aboves idea srry for not using a quote but ur idea of recompensating for ppl who dont attack will be abused for sure. Also, people are in different time zones so this is not fair. I actually have one raid left in my war right now but i am at work and wont get home until the last hour or so of the war and when i last checked we were dominating like 100-10 so i dont want it that the other clan forfeits and some people arent allowed to attack because they were waiting to attack at later dates.

[rwelshjr]

Only way to allow a forfeit button is this.

Say you are #5 and if their #5 attacks you, they would have gotten 300k of each and 1500 de. Now, their number 5 didnt get a chance to attack but you want to quit. You can, but you would owe #5 the loot bonus he would have gained had he had the chance to attack. And it comes from YOUR storages.

This is would happen for every attack that was missed because you quit, every member of the clan pays unless their opposing member already took BOTH attacks.

If even one person doesnt have the funds to cover, you cant forfeit.

This is the first time I have seen a suggestion on a forfeit button that SC might ever consider. So the forfeit comes out of ones own pocket instead of theirs. That would make them willing to allow the shortened time between payouts if they are not footing the bill.

Without playing all scenarios though, there may still be abuse. Picture 2 clans strike a deal everyone puts th out, They each snipe both attacks and surrender real quick. SC pays bonuses on the hits All in 20 minutes. Each declares another war with someone. Deal again, fast snipes and surrender. SC pays bonuses, it happens again, SC pays bonuses. Now clans are collecting 3 bonuses in a couple hours or less rather than collecting them every 2 days. that would run up a bill for SC.

[tmiller1200]

This is the first time I have seen a suggestion on a forfeit button that SC might ever consider. So the forfeit comes out of ones own pocket instead of theirs. That would make them willing to allow the shortened time between payouts if they are not footing the bill.

Without playing all scenarios though, there may still be abuse. Picture 2 clans strike a deal everyone puts th out, They each snipe both attacks and surrender real quick. SC pays bonuses on the hits All in 20 minutes. Each declares another war with someone. Deal again, fast snipes and surrender. SC pays bonuses, it happens again, SC pays bonuses. Now clans are collecting 3 bonuses in a couple hours or less rather than collecting them every 2 days. that would run up a bill for SC.

Well put.. forfeit button would never work... the only improvement I could see to help this is if every attack on both sides was used war would end.. no reason for it to go the whole time then.

[ellogovna14]

If you know you are going to loose, then i think this button would be good.. It beats waiting 10 hours to see yourself loose.

[rwelshjr]

Well put.. forfeit button would never work... the only improvement I could see to help this is if every attack on both sides was used war would end.. no reason for it to go the whole time then.

they could still agree to all put their th out, snipe each other using all attacks in all of 30 minutes, and then get another war going. That would have SC paying out war bonuses at a much higher rate than every 2 days. And you can bet that if such a moneymaking trick because available it would become a fad. SC needs the war cycle to stay a full 48 hours for the sake of keeping their economy balanced.

[warheads123]

It would be way too cheap for a troll co-leader to just forfeit, also, how much loot bonus would u get with a forfeit, also I was thinking that clans could have the option to start the battle day early like there would be a ready button for leaders to press, if both clans click this button, then the battle day would start immediately, no need to wait the 24 hours of preparation day

[tmiller1200]

they could still agree to all put their th out, snipe each other using all attacks in all of 30 minutes, and then get another war going. That would have SC paying out war bonuses at a much higher rate than every 2 days. And you can bet that if such a moneymaking trick because available it would become a fad. SC needs the war cycle to stay a full 48 hours for the sake of keeping their economy balanced.

first I do not think they will ever do any of the mentioned ideas but for the sake of speculation....


I think it would be unlikely to see a clan with their top guys th exposed. that's all it would take. not the whole clan. then who backs down for the decreased bonus?. wouldn't be my clan. it would be easy to trick other clan into using a bunch of loot attacks then hitting a few easy 3 stars then looting their top guy for a bigger bonus. I know this wouldn't change my clan's strategy in wars. Plus now with multiple bases saved, it would be easy to switch at the last min and burn other clan... Plus you would still have to wait the whole prep day so every 25hrs... seems like a lot of work for very little gain

[AxionXD]

This is the first time I have seen a suggestion on a forfeit button that SC might ever consider. So the forfeit comes out of ones own pocket instead of theirs. That would make them willing to allow the shortened time between payouts if they are not footing the bill.

Without playing all scenarios though, there may still be abuse. Picture 2 clans strike a deal everyone puts th out, They each snipe both attacks and surrender real quick. SC pays bonuses on the hits All in 20 minutes. Each declares another war with someone. Deal again, fast snipes and surrender. SC pays bonuses, it happens again, SC pays bonuses. Now clans are collecting 3 bonuses in a couple hours or less rather than collecting them every 2 days. that would run up a bill for SC.

Very good point. I tried to make a compromise that could work, but your exploit is very feasible. I don't think a forfeit button should be implement, with or without my suggested revision.

[Chrisheart]

Huh? They are the winning clan. Define 'better'.

To upgrade stuff there is your definition hahaha