Giant 7 is overpowered!!

[DroogJanus]

This thread has to be trolling?! It makes no sense.

[Matthew81]

Nah, not overpowered at all. I have been playing around with them. Bringing a few is great for farming, but golems are far better tanks in war/trophy pushing due to immunity to spring traps and no added splash damage effects

[badfish1979]

Also, using this same exact logic, you could say any troop is OP.

Just take any max level troop (besides lava hounds) and compare it to the level 1 golem's DPS per housing space.

[Holps]

I,hope,they are overpowered..just started the upgrade 😎

[ClashOfClansNoob]

You can kill 3 lvl 7 giants with a spring trap. And you have a lot of spring traps on TH9/TH10.

[SirSaltySack]

Giants better off on point defenses and single infernos.
golems better on multi, traps, splash.

i could see some bases being stronger/weaker against either depending on setup. Really depends

[loveless2213]

Oh i foresaw this crying thread the moment i read about level 7 giants

[Camja11]

While i think the whole OP is kinda out to lunch with his comparison, you'd have to compare lvl 5 golems to lvl 7 giants to make it proper. Therefore it's 6600 compared to 6300+1260+1260 = 8820. So the golem still far exceeds it in overall health. Not only that, but as a meat shield the golems sole job is to lock on to defences and take the damage while the offensive troops do there thing. With Giants, after the 1st giant dies, that defense can target the next closest raider which could be a wizard, archer, or PEKKA (in the case of teslas)

Giants better off on point defenses and single infernos.
golems better on multi, traps, splash.

i could see some bases being stronger/weaker against either depending on setup. Really depends

i agree except on the point defences. Golems have more overall health and can lock up the defences.

[loveless2213]

I like the update but I think giant 7 is overpowerd

compare it to a golem

golem takes 30 places

6 Giants 30 places

6 Giants = 6000 health

golem lvl 1 = 4500 health


Giant 6 is strong enough


Dont you guys agree?

I'll just list your errors without judging you:

-You are comparing level 1 golems with MAX level giants. If you are comparing max level troops, use level 5 golems.
-A golem is immune to spring traps and receives less total damage from AOE attacks.
-A level 1 golem has 4500*1.4 = 6300 HP.
-6 level 7 giants has 1100*6 = 6600 HP.

[Recruiterbob]

Why didn't they do drags, it the only troop non de still at lvl 4 and is pretty much over powered by loons at upper lvl