Suggest war/defence bases!!

[Emberblade1324]

Ok, let's face it, some people have good defence towers, but thier formation really sucks. You guys know what I'm talking about. That one person who decides to put walls around his barracks or spell factory. This ability would allow the elders, cos and leaders to suggest formations. It will be recieved to them in the mail section and will be private. They will view it and either reject or accept it. In the message, it will say whether it is the war base or normal base.






Pls tell me what you think!!!!!





i am open to suggestions

[SkylerBlue]

We already do this, why the need for a private message?

[Emberblade1324]

We already do this, why the need for a private message?

Ya, we do but its thru da chat and it gets really complicated sometimes. And I don't think u get the idea. The person will get the message, then there will be a button that says view and he will see his village in the same way we see our villages in village edit mode exept it's made by someone else.

[SkylerBlue]

So the leaders take the time to edit other peoples bases.. Can't say I haven't wanted to do this time to time, but I also see that as an incredible invasion of their creative rights, which is a HUGE part of the game. Giving advice is one thing, but remodeling their base for them is an entirely different thing altogether.
I can see its function in the war bases, to an extent. But on their home base I just can't agree. That's like going into someones house and rearranging their furniture then asking then how they like it.
Just my thoughts

[Emberblade1324]

So the leaders take the time to edit other peoples bases.. Can't say I haven't wanted to do this time to time, but I also see that as an incredible invasion of their creative rights, which is a HUGE part of the game. Giving advice is one thing, but remodeling their base for them is an entirely different thing altogether.
I can see its function in the war bases, to an extent. But on their home base I just can't agree. That's like going into someones house and rearranging their furniture then asking then how they like it.
Just my thoughts

Ya, but the thing is that they don't HAVE to accept it, it's thier choice. And the reason a clan was made is to help people out so I guess this feature wouldn't be doing any harm.

[Maneback]

It's a good thing

#1 You keep it personal
#2 That player doesn't need to be online

You can also write a clan mesage but that way it won't be personal so everybody gets a message thats not ment for them.

Edit:

I think i didn't understand this fully. I thought all you wanted to do was send them a message but you're talking about changing a base.

I see why you would want this to happen but i don't think thats a good idea. If you don't like his base just kick him from your clan coz he's not looking to be a nice member - Kicking him sounds harsh like this but its an option. You can also just tell him how to play the game.

[Bresn]

It's easy to make somebody accept a troll base design if they noob.

[PhatAlbert]

This ability would allow the elders, cos and leaders to suggest formations. It will be recieved to them in the mail section and will be private. They will view it and either reject or accept it.

Or do you mean allow Cos, Leader to design the war base then they can ok it?

I feel clash of clans is a collective of individuals -- for better or worse -- making up a diverse clan. A good leader has to communicate via chat to their clan-mates. Implementing such a controlling feature would change the meaning of CoC into more of a medieval "kingdom". Clans are considered "wild" suggesting they all have their own ideas -- the first character is a barbarian for a reason.

[Emberblade1324]

Or do you mean allow Cos, Leader to design the war base then they can ok it?

I feel clash of clans is a collective of individuals -- for better or worse -- making up a diverse clan. A good leader has to communicate via chat to their clan-mates. Implementing such a controlling feature would change the meaning of CoC into more of a medieval "kingdom". Clans are considered "wild" suggesting they all have their own ideas -- the first character is a barbarian for a reason.

No,no,no, you r getting it wrong! The guy will get the message and he will view how his base would look, and then he may accept it or decline it.