Limit donations to maximum 5 players in clan war

[jags]

I have seen that in clan war some times only one or two people donate to everyone and other people behaves with no responsibility. I want to limit donation to maximum 5 players during clan war. This way one player can donate only 5 players at max during clan war.
This will help to develop more co-operation within clan, makes everyone responsible and more active and also reduce burden from one or two players.

[PahPahKahn]

I have seen that in clan war some times only one or two people donate to everyone and other people behaves with no responsibility. I want to limit donation to maximum 5 players during clan war. This way one player can donate only 5 players at max during clan war.
This will help to develop more co-operation within clan, makes everyone responsible and more active and also reduce burden from one or two players.

I am one of the players that do most of the war donations and there is a lot less chaos with designated donors.

[Jietoh]

I have seen that in clan war some times only one or two people donate to everyone and other people behaves with no responsibility. I want to limit donation to maximum 5 players during clan war. This way one player can donate only 5 players at max during clan war.
This will help to develop more co-operation within clan, makes everyone responsible and more active and also reduce burden from one or two players.

I like it. This will also lessen the advantage that certain clans are currently using the game the system to help them win wars. An advanced player who recruits only lower level players for his clan (a TH10 with the rest of his clan TH7 for example) who then uses his advanced troops for his lower mates war castles.

[Not4You]

Nice idea

[pooyan11]

I like it. This will also lessen the advantage that certain clans are currently using the game the system to help them win wars. An advanced player who recruits only lower level players for his clan (a TH10 with the rest of his clan TH7 for example) who then uses his advanced troops for his lower mates war castles.

I am against this.

If a clanmate wants to donate for all of their members, they can. Donating is already limited to five units.
Yes, a TH10 (max troops) will donate for all of his clanmates and it will help them win. The price he is going to pay for that is a lot of elixir and training time.
It is annoying if they are recruiting members specifically for this purpose but a strong clan leader should be allowed to support all his members.

They have only themselves to blame if they are not strong enough. Everybody starts weak. If your opponents are too strong, try lowering trophies to avoid them.

And yes, I have a TH10 clan leader. Also yes that he donates max wiz for cc.
But I have also encountered TH6 with max troops and my clanmates have taught me how to counter them.

It is a considerable in wars but it is not the deciding factor.

Bottomline: Don't add another limit to donating (our current limit is enough)
If you are having a hard time against cc troops, ask clanmates for tips and tactics
If you don't have a clan donator, tough luck (you will get stronger in time)

Thanks for reading. Clash on!

[CircusOfFun]

Hm would rage a lot of people, you see in lots of clans the leader(s) want to take care of the war donations and tell there clan mates not to donate to the war castles. They don't want level 4 barbs and archers in the war castles.... Like c'mon implementing this will set up tons of clans for failure.

[chow13]

You gave me an idea I think this would work a lot better.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...tle-Donation-s

I am against this.

If a clanmate wants to donate for all of their members, they can. Donating is already limited to five units.
Yes, a TH10 (max troops) will donate for all of his clanmates and it will help them win. The price he is going to pay for that is a lot of elixir and training time.
It is annoying if they are recruiting members specifically for this purpose but a strong clan leader should be allowed to support all his members.

They have only themselves to blame if they are not strong enough. Everybody starts weak. If your opponents are too strong, try lowering trophies to avoid them.

And yes, I have a TH10 clan leader. Also yes that he donates max wiz for cc.
But I have also encountered TH6 with max troops and my clanmates have taught me how to counter them.

It is a considerable in wars but it is not the deciding factor.

Bottomline: Don't add another limit to donating (our current limit is enough)
If you are having a hard time against cc troops, ask clanmates for tips and tactics
If you don't have a clan donator, tough luck (you will get stronger in time)

Thanks for reading. Clash on!

That does not work. Clans are matched up based on a calculation of Army Size/Troop level/Troop's Avaliable/Spell's/Defense Buildings/Hero's/Wall Level

[pooyan11]

That does not work. Clans are matched up based on a calculation of Army Size/Troop level/Troop's Avaliable/Spell's/Defense Buildings/Hero's/Wall Level

Really? I thought clan vs clan was based on clan trophies.
All of our enemies have been in the +-2k trophy distance from ours.
I did not know that. Thanks for that new information.

[Tiler]

We only have a few people in my clan with max troops, and not all of them can be online when it's time for prep. The people that have, and are willing to donate max level troops should be allowed to at their heart's desire. Taking away a lot of our level 4 Dragons, level 6 Wizards and level 7 Archers would be quite frustrating to my clan

[SkyAustin]

Ok the War Clan Castle troops is not that big of a deal. 25-40 archers can take out pretty much any troop in there if you lure the troops and then surround them. Also if you use Dragons you don't even have to worry about the Clan Castle. IMO let them donate all high level troops because 1. Not that hard to deal with, 2. You can donate high lvl troops to members for their attacks.