I searched and couldn't find anything quite like my idea.
So currently the clan war releases a 'Most Heroic Attack/Defense' and that got me thinking. Instead of having Supercell just guess which attack was Heroic (which we all know half the time isn't right or doesn't make sense), why not allow the clan leaders to just designate it themselves?
Under the player profile could be a "clan awards" tab that has a list of each award won and how many times it was designated to that player. So one player would have a trophy graphic that says "Most Heroic Attack" and "x3" if they've been given the award 3 times, etc. Right now there are 2, Heroic Attack/Defense, but there could be easily 2 or 3 more that supercell could create such as:
"Offensive MVP" - the player who got the most stars for a clan during a war (or the best stars)
"Defensive MVP" - the player who had the most (or the best) defenses during the war
"Best Team Player" - would go to the one who attacks down and gets stars over just attacking for loot
"Most Heroic Attack" - the single best attack for that war (EXISTS)
"Most Heroic Defense" - the single best defensive stand for that war (EXISTS)
Some wars would result in all trophies being awarded, some wars would result in none, it could be flexible based on the Leaders discretion. This would be a leader permission only. Organized clans and players (CoCs bread and gravy) would eat this up! It would encourage better game play (more serious game play) and would give another perk for the clan environment, making clans more serious and players more likely to be active in the clan. I understand some clans would just give them out willy nilly, but most clans would take it seriously I believe.
These awards could follow the player even if they leave a clan (so other clans can check him/her out and see what designations they've earned) and also could be ejected by a player at his or her will after receiving it or not accepted at all ("You have been awarded the "Offensive MVP" - do you accept?" -Yes/No)
Right now I do send out a clan message after every war designating some of these awards but with the limited characters in clan messaging and, it being just a message and all, it doesn't have the effect that we all want. It's not tangible (so to speak) so there's not as much pride in receiving it, etc.
It's corny but I think people would dig it and I would imagine it wouldn't take a whole lot of development.
I will try to create screen shots for this but I wanted to get a general idea of whether or not people would enjoy this. Ultimately it would be nice to have completely customizable awards but I know that these sorts of customization are another whole level of development (vs having 3-5 set awards that Supercell makes) and are unlikely to ever come to fruition. But even having 3-5 designated clan awards to give out would be a nice little touch for clans, which are the games best feature and what will keep people playing it longer and longer.
____________________________________
Also, completely separate idea would be custom clan titles and increased clan title amounts (Head Ninja instead of leader, having the ability to make 5 titles instead of just 3, etc) and permissions, but that's a whole other issue and I know it's been covered a bunch. Customizable things like that though do take a ton more development so I'm guessing that's why Supercell hasn't done it yet. Although that would greatly enrich the clan experience.
