Previously I thought it was a good idea but I'm not sure anymore.
Last war we had a low player snipe a high th and get most heroic attack which I don't think warrants a bonus. Most heroic defense is usually just which attacked screwed up the worst.
I could see the bonuses but I think the criteria for picking most heroic attack needs to be adjusted if they are going to give bonuses for it because right now it often rewards someone attacking an opponent that is too high for them.
The idea doesn't sound too bad... There definitely shouldn't be a bonus for the person with the most heroic defence, but maybe the most heroic attacker is worthy of a higher loot bonus.
Thank you Milos for the sig pic!!
IGN: Tree-branch