Am I going to get my 900k-1.1 million of each and 4-5k de in this idea? Doubtful. So no, bad idea and nothing is solved. I spend a few thousand de filling war cc and even if I set up and use one attack that is a lot of resources. I know war is not about loot, but if we are in war and the win bonus is in place, I want all of it.Originally Posted by SlightPurple
Just no.
Last edited by Terraist; October 24th, 2014 at 05:09 PM.
Yeah you could, why not?
Just as there are countless clans that exist purely to donate troops, clans will pop up that start wars and immediately concede, just to pump loot into the economy. Top clans and highly organized clans would no doubt attempt to start wars at the same time in order to trade concessions and boost loot for both sides.
Just a terrible, terrible, terrible idea in every way.
I want to try to earn those stars even if the third achievement star is a long haul project. If there were a concede button would I miss the chance to get stars or get unearned six stars?
People will always look for ways to che🅰T the system. Really really sad though.
aside from the possible ways to take advantage of the system, my concern is for the clan that doesnt concede.
Lets say you start your matchup. 10 hours after match is found 12 of the enemy clan members leave. IDK why, but they do. ((this happened recently to us, we watched the other clan members drop like flys)) Maybe that clan leader started the war without telling people. maybe there was someone promoted to co who started the war without permission. Whatever... I know that the clan in question would have conceded if there had been an option. They used a whopping 15 attacks I think...
So now, this clan that just lost 12 out of 30 players wants to concede.
But we already filled the war base CC's with heavy hitter troops, expensive troops. Some of us even started cooking our high level war army. If the other guy concedes than all those expensive troops we put in CC's are WASTED. Utterly totally wasted. Burned elixir.
For some of our clan it is their first war. Now if the other clan concedes they get no experience in the war. They had already discussed tactics and started planning their attacks. If the other clan concedes they lose valuable experience.
If for some reason you know you cannot win, or you lose half your clan mid prep... Why not just buy cheap white flags to place on all the war bases? It would let the other clan know you are not going to try to win, and gives them a chance to practice, and use all their attacks.
Even if you lose the war you get some loot. If you go up against a massivly OP clan then organize your clan to all take turns hitting the bases you know can be starred. At least pull in something.
clan: Wiggy wildlings
Psycho oixie, Founder.
Since you are quoting me, like I said resource will be taken from the losing clan. So what is this "both clans" referring to?
Current system can be abused as it is, but is it?
And no, I'm not serious and I certainly don't think SC will implement a concede feature.
I was thinking of this just the other day and seeing it as an assist to being way outmatched. I have a few additional things to add to the idea.
1. The other clan has the option to accept the surrender and if they accept they have two more options. This would just be one more thing that should be discussed beforehand to plan and get most everyone's opinion on it.
- to end the war and then be able to start another war.
- to let the rest of the war time go on and use their attacks to gain loot and stars. this way you won't have cooked your war troops in vain and you still have time to earn the loot and the stars.
2. The surrendering clan has to have used at least 1/5th of their attacks with a minimum-maximum of success or possibly have a minimum time limit on the concede button. For example they were able to earn three stars in four attacks from their top players on lower bases and decided they were just way outmatched.
3. The conceding clan would have a cool-down timer that would last the rest of the war and they would forfeit all of the rest of their attacks as well as forfeit a higher than loss percentage of the war loot already earned.
